"American Idol" 80's Night

Reader Comments

• 16. Jason Castro!! I have never been "into" A.I before, but Jason Castro caught my eye. He seems so pure and humble. He reminds me so much a my nephew, that I am drawn to him. I think he has a beautiful voice. I will rush out and buy his CD as soon as he wins...yes...wins!! GOOD LUCK JASON!! you have my vote!

  Posted at 10:57AM on 5th 2008 by Dawn

• 17. Oops.....forgot to mention David - he really is an amazing talent and he will go a long way in the music business BUT for this competition (or whatever you want to call it) I just don't think he's going to win it. He's still quite young - his voice needs to mature just a little bit more. I find that right now there is just a little too much of his actual speaking voice being heard...he's got this weird little rasp or something in his voice and you can hear it clear as day when he sings. A maturing voice will take care of that! He is however REALLY GOOD - just not this year!

  Posted at 9:23AM on 5th 2008 by Vicki

• 18. Well I can't say I disagree with you all about Danny - last night wss horrible!!! I think I read somewhere that he rocked it in rehearsals??? I really can't see how - he should be the next one to go...David Cook - AWESOME!!! What a cool take on a really kinda crappy song .. Jason Castro - UNBELIEVABLE!!!!! He and David took last night easy - the hard part would be to choose but I guess my choice would be Jason - he picked a beautiful song and sang it beautifully..... And yes, I definately heard Simon about the stripping - that's fine, at least he didn't bring it up. Hmmm....Paula....what can I say - she needs to stick to either it was good OR it was bad. No speak in between!!

  Posted at 9:14AM on 5th 2008 by Vicki

• 19. It's too bad that VFTW is back to doing what it does worst...or best depending on your view. They are supporting Danny Noriega which is why he stayed and Robbie went home last week. They are also supporting Amanda Overmeyer, which is why Alaina went home instead. At first I supported Amanda as a fellow Hoosier who I thought was different, but she's REALLY bad. Luke was awful last night, as if he never found his niche. He floundered with a very gay sounding song, and he does need to go home, even though I supported him at first as well. The Indiana people really did fall flat this year, and they're being hyped like crazy locally.

  Posted at 9:06AM on 5th 2008 by crys

• 20. Danny totally tanked!~ He did the worst only 2nd to the guy who sang Wham.... Buh Bye you 2 Chicizee makes it to final 12. What I want to know is how we lost a good Rocker last week?? Anyone still scratching their heads???

  Posted at 8:35AM on 5th 2008 by KittyBabe

• 21. ok....danny....you are really making a bad rap for gays....settle down!!!

  Posted at 8:24AM on 5th 2008 by elizabeth

• 22. Jason Castro needs his head shaved and Danny Noriega needs to go home. His attitude, looks and voice are grating on everyone's nerves. Jason can sign but that hair looks like something died on his head!

  Posted at 8:06AM on 5th 2008 by D.R.

• 23. DANNY HAS GOT TO GO LIKE NOW.HE HAS A HORRIBLE ATTITUDE.GOODBYE DANNY.HOPE YOUR GONE TONITE.MICHAEL J,DAVID A,DAVID C. WAY TO GO GUYS.YOU ARE GREAT.

  Posted at 7:52AM on 5th 2008 by DEBBIE

• 24. Did anyone else here Simon comment about David Hernandez stripping to his song? I don't think Simon knew his mic was on. For those of you who still have the show recorded, play back and listen carefully at the end of David's song. You can definitely here Simon saying something about stripping.

  Posted at 7:48AM on 5th 2008 by idol watcher

• 25. if my son got up there and acted like danny did last night i would have gotten on the stage and pulled him off by that purple hair. he needs to go home and hide

  Posted at 7:29AM on 5th 2008 by tonyia

• 26. I just love Jason Castro. He derserves to win it all!! And how good looking is he? Those eyes...... Danny should stay coz he keeps the show fun versus Simon and Ryan. And he can definitely sing....

  Posted at 7:08AM on 5th 2008 by Katie

• 27. David Hernandez is HOT! Archuletta is gonna win tho. He's a total heart throb in the making. Plus...hes very good! And he's totally playing the audience with his shyness like doolittle did.

  Posted at 3:37AM on 5th 2008 by palma909

• 28. Okay, what was up with Paula tonight? Both Randy and Simon had to shut her down when she was spiraling around and around and couldn't get her point across...she needs to skip the meds when she's on national tv.

  Posted at 3:36AM on 5th 2008 by Jules

• 29. I love David Cook, he has been my fave since the first night. I also like David A. and Michael, but I think Idol needs a hard rockin' guy to take this competition! Also, Cook's rendition of "Hello" was amazing. He definitely gets my vote(s).

  Posted at 3:17AM on 5th 2008 by Amy

• 30. Let's all get on the same page. This is a singing competion...not a striptease or sex competion. If it were all 3 then David H would win 2 out of 3. Does it really matter if two...or any number of the guys are gay> NO, it doesn't, so lets stick with the "singing" and cast your votes accordingly. Then after you cast your votes, you can go to the bathroom and get off thinking about any one of these guys that you want. I would still take Ryan Seaqueer any day !!!

  Posted at 1:07AM on 5th 2008 by Juicy Lucy