"American Idol" 80's Night

Reader Comments

• 31. David A was great and so was Michael J and David Cook. Danny really gets on my nerves! The head movements he does looks stupid. He needs to be the next one voted off the island.

  Posted at 12:54AM on 5th 2008 by Sue

• 32. My faves tonight were Michael John, David Cook and Jason Castro. I like Danny's personality, he can sing but he sucked tonight. Archuleta was good but why is he always laughing like a giddy school girl? The stripper has an amazing voice but was mediocre. Luke is def going....he's the weakest. Chickizie deserves to stay but his soul singing is not what's exactly hot on radio, so he's a goner. Although, based on the performances tonight, Danny should join Luke. But everybody loves the sassy gay boy.

  Posted at 12:48AM on 5th 2008 by me me me

• 33. This is to the comment about David coping the style Josh Groban with the song "Imagen" it is TOTALLY FALSE I did go to YOUTUBE and checked it out and I could not find anything....David has been singing like that since he was a little boy!!! If you don't want to vote for him FINE!!,He doesn't need your vote, he has plenty of them I just tried and I can't get through....the line are very busy.

  Posted at 12:39AM on 5th 2008 by lina

• 34. To the comment that David Archuleta copied Josh Groban's version of "Imagine"...the arrangement Archuleta used last week was originally put together by a singer named Eva Cassidy before she died in 1996 at the age of 33. I'm not sure about Groban's version (it sounds similar but not exactly the same), but the first known public performance by him of the song was in a duet at the Nobel Prize gala in 2002. It does sound a lot like the Cassidy arrangement. As for Archuleta, there are videos all over the net of him doing this song on tv in Utah four years ago when he was 13. My guess is Cassidy would be really pleased her version has received so much play and would probably agree that Archuleta nailed her interpretation pretty well.

  Posted at 12:23AM on 5th 2008 by Terry

• 35. i dont care who danny sleeps with, boys or girls, his attitude sucks. if this were 'real life' and not American Idol, they would have @$!#? canned him. he has a lot of growing up to do

  Posted at 12:13AM on 5th 2008 by deb

• 36. Alicia, your son sounds more socially advanced than you are! So what if Danny is out there. You have straights and you have gays. Get over it. The gays are not going anywhere!

  Posted at 12:10AM on 5th 2008 by bocoe2

• 37. To the mother who asked her if Danny likes boys: So what if Danny is gay. The gays are not going anywhere soon.They are here, and queer,GET OVER IT! Your son seems more socially evolved than you!

  Posted at 12:07AM on 5th 2008 by MISTER BOCOE

• 38. David Archuleta is AH-mazing! Hes my favorite guy that has been on American Idol so far.

  Posted at 11:43PM on 4th 2008 by Caitlin

• 39. David Cook was outstanding!! I loved the arrangement of the song and how he sang the song. I hope he takes the title of American Idol. He's got some grit to him not like the other "bubble gum" singers like David A, Danny and Luke Menard. David was actually a little sexy too...

  Posted at 11:38PM on 4th 2008 by julie

• 40. David Cook rocked tonight!! Still in love with Michael J. I agree with Simon on David A. Good, not great. he'll still be in the finals. David H, great voice, but hard to look at him after seeing pics on the internet...hahaha. Danny did great last week. Think he may be gone :( (i still think he's awesome). I think Luke's a gonner...along with Chikizie.

  Posted at 11:29PM on 4th 2008 by gthang

• 41. Why has no one commented on simon saying to Paula.... "Say, I like the way you strip for men" at the end of hernendez's performance?

  Posted at 11:20PM on 4th 2008 by Randy

• 42. Why has no one commented on simon saying to Paula.... "Say, I like the way you strip for men" at the end of hernendez's performance?

  Posted at 11:10PM on 4th 2008 by Randy

• 43. I thought that Luke M. was very good. David A. was gloomy but great. Danny N. is awful. David H. not bad, he is probably better at stripping. Michael J. was also very good. David C. was fair. Jason Castro is bad. I am not impressed with Chickeze. I would love to tell Randy that it is an insult to call a woman Man! For the most part Paula is my favorite and someone should hang Simon. He is the rudest person that I have ever seen. I would love to see someone beat his ass.

  Posted at 10:59PM on 4th 2008 by BILL GLAZIER

• 44. I JUST LOVE THE WAY DAVID ARCHULETA SINGS ---HE IS GREAT ---HOPE HE WINS

  Posted at 10:17PM on 4th 2008 by JEAN

• 45. I JUST LOVE THE WAY DAVID ARCHULETA SINGS ---HE IS GREAT---

  Posted at 10:15PM on 4th 2008 by jean