It's great to see Carly and Amanda on this show. They are both different. Not your average pretty singers. They are both really good but very unique. I love that they do their own thing instead of the same old country singer or Britney type singers.
I really enjoy your website... but your insider comments have been wrong!!! for the past week!!! Can you get someone who can judge talent to be your inside person?
Posted at 11:14AM on March 6th 2008 by michael wood
I think Kady Malloy is a great singer, but didnt do well on Who Wants to Live Forever. I mean, I am a die hard Queen fan, and will compare any cover of their music to the origional, but she could have done better. That song needs to have been belted out, and really sung. She was much to soft, and not nearly as hard hitting as I think she can be.
Carly was HOT YO! Girl had it going on! I mean she was great, Fantastic! Get her a record deal! Oh wait...Someone else should get a chance, isn't this why they call it American Idol and it's for people to get a chance at stardom? :)
UMMM...the pics may be from Top 24...but the songs are the ones they are performing tonight. They were right on with the guys yesterday, and have been right on with the girls so far tonight.
Posted at 8:24PM on March 5th 2008 by has everyone lost their mind?
It's great to see Carly and Amanda on this show. They are both different. Not your average pretty singers. They are both really good but very unique. I love that they do their own thing instead of the same old country singer or Britney type singers.
Posted at 3:58PM on March 6th 2008 by Beth
I really enjoy your website... but your insider comments have been wrong!!! for the past week!!! Can you get someone who can judge talent to be your inside person?
Posted at 11:14AM on March 6th 2008 by michael wood
I think Kady Malloy is a great singer, but didnt do well on Who Wants to Live Forever. I mean, I am a die hard Queen fan, and will compare any cover of their music to the origional, but she could have done better. That song needs to have been belted out, and really sung. She was much to soft, and not nearly as hard hitting as I think she can be.
Posted at 1:30AM on March 6th 2008 by kelly
Carly was HOT YO! Girl had it going on! I mean she was great, Fantastic! Get her a record deal! Oh wait...Someone else should get a chance, isn't this why they call it American Idol and it's for people to get a chance at stardom? :)
Posted at 10:30PM on March 5th 2008 by GreekGirl
Carly = Best Performance of the Night So Far.
Posted at 8:26PM on March 5th 2008 by Bec
UMMM...the pics may be from Top 24...but the songs are the ones they are performing tonight. They were right on with the guys yesterday, and have been right on with the girls so far tonight.
Posted at 8:24PM on March 5th 2008 by has everyone lost their mind?
Hey these aren't tonight top women picks. This is their performance the first week of the Top 24. Boo!!
Posted at 7:48PM on March 5th 2008 by pam