"American Idol" Top Eleven

Reader Comments

• 16. Cheekize was great. David A was the BEST by far closely followed by David Cook and Carly. It's hard for singers to be locked into one group or singers song's. I like it when they have more of a choice, like the 60s, 90's etc.

  Posted at 2:36AM on 19th 2008 by B3

• 17. Ok... Am I the only one that thinks Carly's accent changes every week. Sometimes she only has a hint of an accent, sometimes she doesn't have one at all! And this week she must have had the Spirit of Saint Patrick in her, because her accent was really deep. I'm no doggin' the Irish, but she needs to figure out who she is.

  Posted at 2:31AM on 19th 2008 by Shay

• 18. i actually cannot stand the beatles as singers, but as writers, amazing. tonite Carly and David A were the best. bottom 3? chikezie, kristi lee, and probably ramielle. going home? kristi lee

  Posted at 1:55AM on 19th 2008 by deb

• 19. I can understand that the under twenty crowd does not like the Beatles. But don't whine.turn off the show & watch the results tomorrow night. You can put on MTV for a few hours & lay awake in bed all night trying to figure out what the hell they were saying.

  Posted at 1:29AM on 19th 2008 by Dee Anthony

• 20. You can tell the people who hate the Beatles are complete morons who don't actually know their music. You think you sound cool saying those things, but actually you reveal yourselves as the dummies you are. You douches actually think rap, and $@?!# like Britney Spears is music. Bwaaaahhh! David A has respect for all kinds of music and it shows.

  Posted at 1:21AM on 19th 2008 by so many morons

• 21. Geesh, yes, I agree the Beatles suck as well. I'm sure their music was fine way baaaacck when, but their songs sound dated now.

  Posted at 1:06AM on 19th 2008 by IdolMan

• 22. The girls standing in front by the stage are getting very annoying with the screaming and waving hands in the air. Shut the F up during the song so we can hear the performance.

  Posted at 12:50AM on 19th 2008 by TJ

• 23. "IMAGINE"

  Posted at 11:54PM on 18th 2008 by IMAGINE

• 24. People CAN hate the beatles and not be idiots. I hate the beates music, always have. I did not watch tonight because I did not want to listen to more "slitting your wrist" music. Just to assume you MUST love the beatles is stupid. Just how it is assumed that you must love certain movies. Beatles suck, plain and simple. If you assume that EVERYONE must love the Beatles then you are just stupid.

  Posted at 11:40PM on 18th 2008 by SC

• 25. All of the idiots who are complaining about The Beatles music need to watch something else because this is a music show and they evidentally know NOTHING at all about music. You could have a whole season of nothing but Beatle's songs and it would be a great show. Get a clue and go away.

  Posted at 11:03PM on 18th 2008 by Emily

• 26. David Archuleta is so awsome-he sang his butt off. Can Michael Johns get kicked off already, I don't know who told him he could sing but they lied.

  Posted at 9:48PM on 18th 2008 by Smooch

• 27. hey what song did jason sing tonight?What songs did they all sing????pLEASE SOMEBODY LET ME KNOW SOON

  Posted at 8:58PM on 18th 2008 by Keri

• 28. I can't imagine ANYONE calling Beatles songs, "boring". I guess some people -most born after 1980, do not know good music, songs written and sung by the actual artist! Great to have another Beatles week. The songs are pure classics!

  Posted at 8:52PM on 18th 2008 by Laurie

• 29. I can't imagine ANYONE calling Beatles songs, "boring". I guess some people -most born after 1980, do not know good music, songs written and sung by the actual artist! Great to have another Beatles week. The songs are pure classics!

  Posted at 8:52PM on 18th 2008 by Laurie

• 30. Don't be so down on David Cook for copying the arrangement of Doxology, when COWBOY (stand up like a woman for craps sake) Krispy Lee stole the Faithfully arrangement (that was't very good) from Katie Austin!! Check out you tube for Katies performance..she nails it!! If it wasn't for guys wanting to F... Kristy she wouldn't even be there still!! American Idol is all about ratings not real music talent!

  Posted at 8:46PM on 18th 2008 by musicfan