"American Idol" Survivors

Reader Comments

• 1. On the part about David Cook, they suppose to put 1982 instead of 1983 because he and the song wasn't born 1983, they were born in 1982.

  Posted at 6:42PM on 17th 2008 by p.atheresa@yahoo.com

• 2. there r all good!! but ithink last year was the best season!!!

  Posted at 7:56PM on 1st 2008 by kc

• 3. They're all good or they would'nt be here right?.......But Jason you are steamin!!!!!

  Posted at 12:19PM on 27th 2008 by Sandy

• 4. DAVID COOK IS AMAZING. nothing else needs to be said. He has amazing arrangements and is probably the most original on the show. He should win!!!! and even if he doesn't i will still buy whatever he comes out with. as for Kristy Lee Cooke, she needs to leave. She is just some blond who has a small amount of talent. She is only getting through the competition, in my opinion, because people think she is hot and don't really care about talent. as for who is leaving, although it should be Kristy. it will most likely be Ramiel, I love her, but she just isn't that inspiring.

  Posted at 6:57PM on 26th 2008 by Ace

• 5. i think that jason castro should get a hair cut, and get rid of those dreads! he has the prettiest eyes ever, and they would look so much better with shorter hair! i really don't like kristy, she has NEVER had a good preformance and i don't think ramielle is doing so good either. but i LUV chickezie! he's so cute, but i don't think he'll win. i like carly and david cook, i think they could be the next american idol!!!

  Posted at 6:35PM on 26th 2008 by sara

• 6. i think that jason castro should get a hair cut, and get rid of those dreads! he has the prettiest eyes ever, and they would look so much better with shorter hair! i really don't like kristy, she has NEVER had a good preformance and i don't think ramielle is doing so good either. but i LUV chickezie! he's so cute, but i don't think he'll win. i like carly and david cook, i think they could be the next american idol!!!

  Posted at 6:35PM on 26th 2008 by sara

• 7. David Cook should win! He told us he was doing someone else arrangement and knocked it out of the park! Brooke is also terrific but needs to be a bit careful. Carly is good but not my idol choice. Syesha hit her Peter Principle last night, good but that's the best she can do. Michael is cute but limited and seems to only do well now and then. Goodbye Rameille and Jason....Kristy has a very good voice but no stage prescence or style of her own. The little kid David is sooo overrated and has now shown he is a mini Harry Connick Jr. Chickeze... well I luv ya but not an idol. ROCK ON DAVID COOK!

  Posted at 11:36AM on 26th 2008 by CessileClam

• 8. David Cook can sing ANYTHING! He is so awesome...singing, arranging, playing. This guy has major talent and I would buy every song he has already done and lok forward to all future hits! He is my American Idol!

  Posted at 11:27AM on 26th 2008 by CessileClam

• 9. I think you need to be up to 28 to audition (enter AI)....and that's what Michael did :) probably auditioned before oct 2007.

  Posted at 10:13AM on 26th 2008 by laloca

• 10. Although I loved Michael's song, did anyone besides me notice that "We Are the Champions" is from 1977, not 1978? I hope it doesn't disqualify him!

  Posted at 10:06AM on 26th 2008 by Barb

• 11. I'm confused.... I thought they had to sing songs from the year they were born? So, how is it that David A. sings John Farnam's song "Your the Voice" that came out in 1986, when he was born in 1990?

  Posted at 10:06AM on 26th 2008 by Mike

• 12. I think that David Archuleta has a sincereness about him that makes him very likeable. I think he is a sweet boy. He is very genuine. I didn't know the song he sang last night, but it is definetely something I would listen to again.

  Posted at 9:59AM on 26th 2008 by Lora In Kentucky

• 13. I absolutely ADORE Michael Johns....the best so far. He is a super star, he sings awesome and he is totally hot!!

  Posted at 9:57AM on 26th 2008 by laloca

• 14. Michael Johns is 30! I thought you had to be no older than 28 to be on the show. WTF?

  Posted at 9:48AM on 26th 2008 by Linda

• 15. OK - NOW I'M GETTING REALLY ANNOYED WITH YOU GUYS .... DAVID COOK DID NOT RIP OFF ANYONE'S ARRANGEMENT - WHEN RYAN INTRODUCED HIM HE TOLD US HE WAS DOING SOMEONE ELSE'S VERSION!!! YOU PEOPLE MUST LISTEN BEFORE BITCHING....AND BY THE WAY - ON ELEANOR RIGBY I DON'T THINK HE ACTUALLY TOOK CREDIT FOR HIS VERSION...I DID HEAR HIM SAY THAT HE WAS INSPIRED TO SING IT (OR SOMETHING SIMILAR) SO STUFF IT - ALTHOUGH HE DOES NEED I THINK TO DO SOMETHING A WEE BIT DIFFERENT HE'S OBVIOUSLY TOP DRAWER MATERIAL AND PROBABLY WILL WIN! DAVID ARCHULETTA WHILE SINGING AN UNKNOWN SONG DID A VERY GOOD JOB LAST NIGHT AND I HIGHLY ENJOYED IT...STILL NEEDS TO MATURE BUT THAT BOY IS AMAZING!! EVERYONE ELSE DID OK JOBS - BUT I THINK THIS WEEK IT WILL BE EITHER MICHAEL JOHNS OR RAMIELLE...AND THAT'S MY 2 CENTS WORTH!

  Posted at 9:13AM on 26th 2008 by Vicki