"American Idol" Survivors

Reader Comments

• 46. I do not like Kristy or Ramiele. They bore me to tears. Kristy reminds me too much of Trisha Yearwood..who also bores me to tears. GO CARLY AND DAVID C!!!

  Posted at 5:48PM on 25th 2008 by jt

• 47. I am just happy that Amanda is gone. I could not bear to watch another week of her screaming. Every song sounded the same. I think Seyesha, David and Jason will be the top three singers tonight.

  Posted at 5:46PM on 25th 2008 by Pat

• 48. 1. syesha's song is so predictable. i hope she leaves us tomorrow night! 2. ramiele - alone? what were you thinking? you def. going to be in the bottom 3 tomorrow night. 3. kristy your my favorite. i hope you do really good with your song even though i think its the wrong choice but yeah i already know the judges are gonna say - SAFE! bottom 3: syesha, ramiele, kristy bottom 2: syesha, kristy leaving us tomorrow night is: SYESHA!

  Posted at 5:44PM on 25th 2008 by Mikkkal

• 49. Cant we just have a line for those of us who want to vote Kristy Lee OFF?!?! Please IDOL? Im begging here!

  Posted at 5:42PM on 25th 2008 by Wants to PUKE

• 50. KKK Kristy will nail that song. It is well written, and can be sung from the heart. Some hate it because it represents, recognizes, and acknowledges all that makes America GREAT. But most of us love America, and this song is right in her wheelhouse...if she nails it, and I think she will, guess who's goin' home...buh bye to the lying fake plant Carly Henessey Smithson whateverthehell her name really is.

  Posted at 5:41PM on 25th 2008 by Justice Alito

• 51. I think David Cook will be awesome! And I can't wait to see Chikezie because I love him!

  Posted at 5:40PM on 25th 2008 by CC

• 52. GO DAVID ARCHULETA!! He is so cute! Happy Birthday Jason!

  Posted at 5:40PM on 25th 2008 by Jenny

• 53. How utterly predictable for Carly to sing "Total Eclipse of the Heart" And how horribly corny for KLC to do "God Bless America". I think Rami singing Heart is the risk she needed to take. Hope it pans out for her.

  Posted at 5:38PM on 25th 2008 by pam

• 54. Jason Castro looks like my niece!

  Posted at 5:36PM on 25th 2008 by anonymous

• 55. CAN'T WAIT TO SEE JASON! I LOOOOVE HIM!!!!!

  Posted at 5:34PM on 25th 2008 by Claudia M

• 56. I can't believe Carly picked Total Eclipse of the Heart. It's been done before, there were so many other great songs she could have picked. And Ramiele doing Heart...geeeezzzuz. I can almost bet right now that she will completely butcher it. Can't wait to see Jason Castro and David C, though!

  Posted at 5:31PM on 25th 2008 by Melly

• 57. Kristy needs to go. God Bless the USA, how corny. Somebody should pick these peoples songs for them.

  Posted at 5:31PM on 25th 2008 by candace

• 58. My God, Like, they're the same age as you! Like.. wow!

  Posted at 5:29PM on 25th 2008 by You're a dork

• 59. Yeah, there is no way Ramiele can sing Heart. Carrie Underwood was able to pull it off fantastically, so no matter how well she sings it it will never top that.

  Posted at 5:19PM on 25th 2008 by Erin

• 60. sorry but there is no way that brooke is only 24 years old... maybe 34...

  Posted at 5:19PM on 25th 2008 by tiluel