"American Idol" Top Twelve

Reader Comments

• 1. David's dad should back off, becuase he is being waaayyy too mean to his angelic son! BACK OF JEFF! He does look like a douchebag... Anywho, VOTE FOR DAVID ARCHULETA!! Did you notice how the sweetie was always smiling in these pics??

  Posted at 10:42AM on 12th 2008 by Heather

• 2. Brooke is awesome, I want her to win..She is not only beautiful, but genuine, and stylish.

  Posted at 3:06PM on 8th 2008 by Gina

• 3. I think only David Archuleta needs a bodyguard, to keep away his overbearing dad..... Also why is Blake Lewis tagging along? Is the record biz not what he had hoped?

  Posted at 9:59AM on 6th 2008 by The_Repo_Girl

• 4. I love Carly Smithson she cool and Awesome Rockstar Singer I hope she will win the Competition. instead MJ Michael Jonh suckaaaaaaaaa up the song very stuoid and I like Carly so much I want her to win to win over Michael for good my mom and I hate Michael so much we want him out for good you Michael you stupid and Lazy Singer you are out. so I want Carly kick some ass the songs are very good and Marvelous very Rock on Carly you are my favorite and Syesha Mecado too she great the song like Whitney Houston gtreat song

  Posted at 7:51AM on 2nd 2008 by Bich Lien Tran my mom the Fan

• 5. I'm surprised that David Arch.'s daddy is so very present with all of the bad press buzzing around. Surprised David doesn't pick his mom to go instead. Does this kid have an adult family member who doesn't just want to exploit him? I agree with someone else about the use of Bodyguards, why? Can't they just have a security team present on the property, or use some of that handy police tape? The bodyguards they chose I guess are there for the possible stray crazed 13yr old fan with a semi-automatic weapon?!? Anywhooooo....

  Posted at 2:45PM on 1st 2008 by AnotherInternetCritic

• 6. Carly definitely looks pregnant. I didn't notice she was covering her face so I had to look again. What is she going to do if she becomes a real celebrity? I think there are more pictures of Blake than anyone else. Why are they taking pictures of him? This is about this season's Idols. I guess that is the cheapest way to promote his new album. Only three of my fave, David C. =(

  Posted at 5:08PM on 21st 2008 by StLChik

• 7. What ever happend to Blake Lewis.Does he have reored out.He shold hook up with Linkin Park that would be coool.

  Posted at 6:26AM on 20th 2008 by mike

• 8. What ever happend to

  Posted at 6:22AM on 20th 2008 by Mike

• 9. Looks as if Carly is trying to keep her hair out of her face. Wow a lot of mean comments.

  Posted at 3:57PM on 17th 2008 by Shawna

• 10. Blake Lewis could learn a thing or two by hanging with this seasons guys. What a poser! Go Chikezie babeeee! Go home Carly!

  Posted at 9:49AM on 17th 2008 by diva_south

• 11. jeff archuleta the overbearing stagedad is there too??? i think that'll be tmth for david a!

  Posted at 10:24PM on 13th 2008 by amber

• 12. Jason Castro is way way way cute.

  Posted at 7:01PM on 12th 2008 by Chandler

• 13. That Large dud with the goatee is AWESOME!!!

  Posted at 5:20PM on 11th 2008 by Kotton

• 14. why does blake always think he is something special???? he isnt any better than the other ppl

  Posted at 3:45PM on 11th 2008 by Monica

• 15. We do all of these people try to act like real big celebrities...whoopeeee they aren't...half of the girls cant even sing...but most of the guys can...the only person that can be proud of their singing is David Archuleta cuz he is the best

  Posted at 3:42PM on 11th 2008 by Monica