"American Idol" Typecasting

Reader Comments

• 1. I have been hugged by Sanjaya ,believe me ...he is not gay. If you could have seen him kiss Gina,you would also know he is not gay,however,it does not matter.Sanjaya is a gifted singer,but people like stupid,mean Blake, keep putting mean comments everywhere he can.He doesn<t get Kharma.Judge ye not,lest ye be judged !

  Posted at 1:35AM on 1st 2009 by heather

• 2. I love Sanjaya. People have to stop !$#@? saying mean things about him. IT IS REALLY PISSING ME THE !$?@# OFF. ONE MORE BAD THING ABOUT SANJAYA AND I WILL SUE EVERY SINGLE ?@!$# SANJAYA HATER. TO ALL YOU SANJAYA HATERS. YOU GUYS ALL SING LIKE SOMEONE BARFING INTO A MICROPHONE.

  Posted at 8:31AM on 15th 2008 by Anna

• 3. Clay can sing ,that's all that matters. The other guy needs to take lessons, the want to be tiny tim.bla

  Posted at 7:53PM on 30th 2008 by shiney sue

• 4. Clay Akins is a wonderful singer ...Ruben is too...what Ruben needed to do is lose weight..so he could proforms on stage

  Posted at 7:05PM on 30th 2008 by jessie james

• 5. Sanjaya is by far my favorite contestant that has ever been on that show. I don't know why people made fun of him and said he couldn't sing. His voice was beautiful! And who really cares if he's gay or not? Nothing's wrong with that! i will always be a fanjaya!

  Posted at 6:41PM on 30th 2008 by Aly

• 6. I personally think they all deserve a little credit for having the guts to compete, the talent to at least make the show, and the courage to chase a dream at all costs. Anyone else out there fall in to that category? Oh yeah, do you bitch about the government but neglect your responsibility to vote? If so, quit bitchin. Thanks

  Posted at 5:29PM on 30th 2008 by dave

• 7. Kinds weird, huh?

  Posted at 5:25PM on 30th 2008 by Em

• 8. Clay has a wonderful voice...I was a little disappointed in the direction his image changed... Sanjaya has stage appeal, and a voice, but not quite fitting The American Idol... Maybe his age is a part of it..

  Posted at 5:20PM on 30th 2008 by nita rikas

• 9. Both are incredibly gay.However,Clay has a lot of talent.Sanjaya sucks.

  Posted at 4:02PM on 30th 2008 by Dean

• 10. Sanjaya is a kid with mediocre talent at best, who, because of the younger teenage girls, was allowed to continue on the show far longer than he should have been.

  Posted at 3:18PM on 30th 2008 by jackrabbitslim

• 11. They should not put Sanjaya in the same place with Klay Aken. Clay is on Broadway, and Sanjaya I don't know where.Klay should have been the real American Idol, What Ruben did? Just thinking to sue people, may be he is already broke.LOL

  Posted at 2:42PM on 30th 2008 by DD.