Hello Dolly! What the Idol's are Singing!

Reader Comments

• 1.

  Get over it. Dolly's definitely the star and these little people are struggling to find their voice in hers and it's not happening. Whitney tried and it was the easiest million dolly ever made. No one else ever will. Keep trying American Idol!!!

  Posted at 1:12AM on 13th 2009 by joe perez

• 2.

  The best thing about the whole Dolly night...was Dolly Parton herself. They should have just kicked off the idols and made it 100% Dolly night. She, truly, is an Idol.

  Posted at 8:58AM on 2nd 2008 by Adrianna

• 3.

  As a personal big fan of Dolly, we grew up listening to her music... and for the first time last night I couldn't watch Idol. It was in my opinon HORRIBLE! No one done a very good job at all. They are too far in to start putting it on cruise control now.

  Posted at 8:29AM on 2nd 2008 by Tink

• 4.

  thank god you,ve all stopped talking about David "the prodigy child" Arch - egh I can't be bothered to spell his name. Syesha - no personalty, Brooke - I don't trust anyone that hasn't seen a dirty/horror movie, jason - just weird looking, would you buy an album with his mug on the front,Micheal - snore,Ramiele - who, Kirsty - give it up girl no ones that all American,David C could be okay if his hearts lasts and his blood pressure dosen't go through the roof again

  Posted at 8:26AM on 2nd 2008 by kerry jago

• 5.

  <3 Jason Castro TMZ needs to make his picture bigger in their little AI photo collages. Hotness.

  Posted at 11:50PM on 1st 2008 by Aiei

• 6.

  Ramiele needs 2 stay. So does David Archuleta.

  Posted at 10:19PM on 1st 2008 by Khylee

• 7.

  Raimele - YUCK! Kristy - YUCK!

  Posted at 9:03PM on 1st 2008 by kim

• 8.

  Wikipedia states about "I Will Always Love You": Dolly Parton wrote the song in 1973 and it was released a year later, having been produced by Bob Ferguson. She has told numerous interviewers over the years that she wrote it for her one-time partner and mentor Porter Wagoner, with whom she was having a business splitting at the time. Recorded on June 17, 1973 in RCA's Studio "B" in Nashville, the song was included on Parton's album Jolene, and was released as a follow-up single, after the Country chart-topping success of the title track, in April 1974 (see 1974 in music). The single reached number one on the Billboard Country Singles chart a month later, but had just modest success on the pop charts. The lyrics express a bittersweet and poignant ode to an ex-lover, and are delivered with Parton's twang.

  Posted at 9:01PM on 1st 2008 by BeeBee

• 9.

  I'm not really fimilar with country music but the only song that I know is "I'll Alway's Love You" & that was by Whitney Houston. I agree with whoever said that Syesha needs to stop with the diva ballads. Her voice isn't stron enough to pull it off & she better be crossing her fingers for tonight.

  Posted at 8:49PM on 1st 2008 by mellabelle

• 10.

  i cant wait for the show...........hope jason will survive this week till the next week till the next week until the final night..yay!!! go jason!!!WHOOOOOOOOOOOP! http://www.y o u tube.com/AI7JASONCASTROTV subscribe!!!

  Posted at 8:11PM on 1st 2008 by kiero

• 11.

  "Islands in the Stream" was written by the BeeGees.

  Posted at 7:24PM on 1st 2008 by Sue

• 12.

  i'm so excited for tonight! can't wait to see jason castro and david cook. i bet they are both going to have great performances. brook should be good too. i wonder how kristy lee crap...i mean cook will do. :/

  Posted at 7:17PM on 1st 2008 by melly

• 13.

  "I Will Always Love You" was written so many years ago by Dolly with Porter Waggoner in mind. (After she had left him and went out on her own) It was written for HER to sing, doubt if Whitney or others who've sung it were even born then.

  Posted at 7:13PM on 1st 2008 by Kat38

• 14.

  I really wanted someone to sing Me and LIttle Andy and i wanted Brooke to sing He's Alive. She would have blown that one away.

  Posted at 7:01PM on 1st 2008 by DollyFan

• 15.

  "I Will Always Love You" was not "tailor made" for Whitney Houston, as another poster stated. It was a song Dolly sang in the musical The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas back in 1982. Good flick!

  Posted at 6:55PM on 1st 2008 by Trix