Hello Dolly! What the Idol's are Singing!

Reader Comments

• 16. Coat of many colors is about Dolly's coat being pieced together by her mother w/ different pieces of material that she has on hand.

  Posted at 6:53PM on 1st 2008 by hjj

• 17. Jason Castro will be amazing tonight and the judges are goin to LOVE it. PERFECT song choice for him!!!

  Posted at 6:44PM on 1st 2008 by Lindsey

• 18. Jason Castro will be amazing tonight and the judges are goin to LOVE it. PERFECT song choice for him!!!

  Posted at 6:43PM on 1st 2008 by Lindsey

• 19. David Cook's choice could be interesting. Love Brooke's too.

  Posted at 6:40PM on 1st 2008 by Jen

• 20. I'M PRETTY SURE THAT "I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU" WAS TAYLOR-MADE FOR THE INCOMPARABLE LEONA LEWIS- YOUTUBE IT....ITS HER SINGING IT LIVE ON X-FACTOR....AND BLOWS WHITNEY OUT OF THE WATER....NO ONE COULD EVER COMPARE!

  Posted at 6:35PM on 1st 2008 by LEONA FAN...

• 21. I bet "9 - 5" and "Islands in the Stream" are group songs, and those are her best. Actually the best that she wrote is "I Will Always Love You", which was taylor made for Whitney Houston. Syesha has got to stop with the Whitney songs, she's going to kill her chances.

  Posted at 6:28PM on 1st 2008 by Jimi

• 22. I was looking forward to hearing Coat of Many Colors tonight, but now that I know Kristy is going to sing it, I think I'll pass. She doesn't interest me at all. Sorry the song went to her.

  Posted at 6:24PM on 1st 2008 by Beth Holliday

• 23. Coat of Many Colors...Kristy? That is the one choice (other than Syseha's idiocy) that really stands out as a mistake. She does not have the chops for it. 2 Doors down would have been great for her. All the rest have a fighting chance.

  Posted at 6:16PM on 1st 2008 by Randomx6

• 24. "9 To 5" was going to be Chikezie's song had he stayed. That's why no one is singing it.

  Posted at 6:14PM on 1st 2008 by jwipe

• 25. "9 To 5" was going to be Chikezie's song had he stayed. That's why no one is singing it.

  Posted at 6:14PM on 1st 2008 by jwipe

• 26. "9 To 5" was going to be Chikezie's song had he stayed. That's why no one is singing it.

  Posted at 6:13PM on 1st 2008 by jwipe

• 27. Its All Wrong, But Its All Right and Appalacian Memories are GREAT songs - I am SO excited about tonite's show! Dolly rocks! She is so personable and down-to-earth - and funny as hell! We are in for a great show...

  Posted at 6:09PM on 1st 2008 by james

• 28. AMAZING choice for BROOKE.

  Posted at 5:58PM on 1st 2008 by bryan

• 29. Not very good song choices and the ones that were picked are being sung by the wrong people.

  Posted at 5:58PM on 1st 2008 by Jack Mitchell

• 30. I'm glad that "Jolene" and "Travelin' Thru" are being sung. I'm not familiar with Kristy Lee Cook's song but I previewed it on iTunes and it seems to have a strong Christian bend to it. How strategic! More pandering to keep herself in the competition! Can't say the girl ain't smart! "Travelin' Thru" seems like far too punchy and upbeat a song for Jason though. Hope he does it justice. And Brooke better deliver on "Jolene."

  Posted at 5:54PM on 1st 2008 by heythatscoolyeah