"Idol" Top 5 Perform

Reader Comments

• 1. OK U GUYS STOP HATING! just because someone acts a certain way on tv dont mean they are like that! personally, i think ur all 10 year old who have no life but to sit at the computer and talk bad about people u WISH U WERE! instead of hatin....why dont u support them? i would like to see if any of u had the balls to get up on stage and sing in front of millions of people! if they are up there its because they have great talent...some more than others but i still love all of them! i cant believe u people...u guys are a disgrace to ur kind and human beings! maybe if u supported the instead of criticized on EVERYTHING they do maybe they could shake off a lil nerve and be themselves on stage! all of u guys are a-holes....and yes they probably hate u too.

  Posted at 8:30PM on 15th 2008 by MisS_CooKiE<3

• 2. It's 2008 and this ?#!$@ is still on television?! God damn. Who the #!?$@ knew?!

  Posted at 7:43PM on 12th 2008 by no

• 3. i can't stand brooke. i'm so glad she got voted off. she's such a poser and was always talking back to the judges if they had anything bad to say. oh, and the raspy voice, i think she does it for attention. good riddance brooke, you got too far in the competition. better stick with baby sitting and singing at coffee houses (where people don't have to pay to hear you sing).

  Posted at 11:07PM on 10th 2008 by virginia girl

• 4. well i think that brooke white sucks,she always defends herself when she didnt perfom well.and i think that sysha is the best and she really has a unique voice.her last night perfomance was brilliant,even simon thougth that it was sexy i think she has the talent,and she deserves to win as it also applies to others.but i think that all the contestents are very good.but if i were to choose the winner it would definetly be saysha.because she really has talent and can relate well to the audiences.i think shes the bomb.

  Posted at 4:49AM on 9th 2008 by AUDREY

• 5. The 2 davids and syesha are the only talent there is left and if i see jason for some reason "pulling through" and someone else "with talent"gets the boot then theres some dumb computers reading those votes......

  Posted at 7:37PM on 7th 2008 by blake

• 6. jason realy needs to go he's horrible beyond all recognition if he keeps this up ill go back to the conclusion that this show is rigged.

  Posted at 7:32PM on 7th 2008 by josh

• 7. OMG!! I love David Cook! he is gonna be the overall winner cuz he can sing unlike everyone else in the compotiotion!

  Posted at 7:30AM on 2nd 2008 by Courtney

• 8. Jason has no talent and can't sing he should have gone a long time ago, they have let some very good singers go that should not have gone. I hope Jason goes this week tired of seening him week after week be gone no talent can't sing good bye

  Posted at 8:20PM on 1st 2008 by Micahel

• 9. they made the right choice in voting off brooke.next is braid boy. i think david A. is a one trick dog but can sing rings around cook.usually the ones that get voted off early do better with contracts than the winners or runners up.the winner has to abide by the contract of american idol.all the rest can make thier own deal,so there is no big reward for coming in first.syesha will go the way of jennifer hudson and fantasia.it's hard to belive that with all the talent out there this is the best the judges can get.get a life simon..

  Posted at 5:56PM on 1st 2008 by michael

• 10. Brooke and Jason need to GO HOME ASAP..He is boring (falling off my chair everytime he sings) and Brooke (has this dumb stupid face, forget her lyrics half the time, and is too emotional), David THE SMALL ONE, is CRAP, America thinks he's WOW (probably the old folks and the 5yo's vote for him) and Syesha should go join Clay Aiken in a Broadway show.....leaves DAVID COOK..he's a true good singer, presonnality, sweetness and bod..GO DAVID C GO..

  Posted at 12:09PM on 30th 2008 by susieq

• 11. Syesha and the 2 David's are the three best on the show. However, for some reason Syesha is not getting the respect that she deserves. She and David A are the only two that come each week as if they really want to win. The other act as if they know they have enough family and friends to get them through, regardless of how horrible they sound. Jason, was one of my favorites, but he feels he has it made and his perfomances show his attitude. Syesha will not win, but she has the showmanship, the voice and the attitude to be a #1 performer with a #1 show and song.

  Posted at 11:21AM on 30th 2008 by Elaine

• 12. haha totally agree about brooke. SHE SUCKS! she always looks like she is about to cry, and she always is defending herself.... if you have to do it that much you shouldn't be there.

  Posted at 9:54AM on 30th 2008 by Elyssa

• 13. Brooke blows. Her performance was horrible last night, and she has a nasally voice. You call that talent??? Give me a break. Horse face needs to go and retire and give birth to Mormon babies.

  Posted at 9:49AM on 30th 2008 by Brooke Blows!

• 14. Ok, i don't know why half the people here commmenting are bashing David Cook and Jason Castro. First off David Cook is the best in the competition this year. He's deff. one of my favorites. Now with Jason Castro he is my all time favorite person that ever came on the show. I don't know why people are saying he has no talent, blah blah blah. He sounds like freakin Jack Johnson he has that layed back style and he doesn't have a huge voice. its ok. But with people who are saying Jason sucks, your basically bashing every other person who sings with that style. GET OVER IT!

  Posted at 9:43AM on 30th 2008 by Lou

• 15. Clean out your freaking ears people! Brooke White sucks, and her voice is pure crap. She is no better than Carmen the goat girl. She had overstayed her welcome for over a month.

  Posted at 9:37AM on 30th 2008 by Karen