"Idol" Top 5 Perform

Reader Comments

• 16. I like all five contestants that are left a lot. I have not liked Syesha as much as the others because I thought she was very boring in the beginning, but she does have a great voice. I think that my favorite contestant is Brooke White. I like that she doesn't have a big voice. It's nice to have something different. It's funny how angry we can get. Season 4 I was a Vonzell Solomon fan and was so upset when Carrie Underwood won. However, I bought both her CDs. Season 5 I liked Katherine McPhee, but did not buy her CD. Since then I have become a little more objective because song choice on American Idol is one thing. Song choice on your own CD is another.

  Posted at 2:39AM on 30th 2008 by greenmommy

• 17. SPINELLI, your an insensitive DUMB ASS. Do you hear him talking about his brother? No. So he has his initials on his guitar, thats a sweet and loving thing to do not pimpin. As for helping arrange for his brother to come see him/David perform live in a potential and most likely life changing event it must be very comforting to his brother and I am sure as taxing as it must have been on his health it probably gave him a shot in the arm to hold on. Unfortunately this may the last time his brother gets to see David perform but I am sure it was well worth it. David Cook does not get my vote because of his brother but because I think he is the best and most original singer in the group. Although with that said, I hope he doesn't win because I don't want Simon to 'own' him.

  Posted at 2:14AM on 30th 2008 by oh fleezzz

• 18. David Cook has done nothing but pimp out his sick brother most of the season. He is a disgrace and if he wins, will be as big a bomb as Ruben Studdard was to Clay Aiken

  Posted at 12:43AM on 30th 2008 by spinelli

• 19. David Cook is AMAZING!!! everything he sings is AWESOME~~~ i can not wait until he has a record out...sure hope he will do Hello.i so want that song in the full version and notice itunes doesnt offer it!!! I guess they are waiting to make the biggggg bucks off of it!!!

  Posted at 12:03AM on 30th 2008 by El

• 20. david cook need to go home!

  Posted at 11:57PM on 29th 2008 by amt

• 21. Archie was amazing! coming to America was as simon said VERY clever

  Posted at 11:55PM on 29th 2008 by Sarah

• 22. this is sooo awful!!!!!!

  Posted at 11:25PM on 29th 2008 by kathy

• 23. Seriously I have never heard anything as funny as watching David A singing coming to Amewica! hahhahahahahah

  Posted at 10:40PM on 29th 2008 by Shirley

• 24. I think Brooke is a sweetheart. I love her voice. David Cook is great too!! I liked Carly as well.

  Posted at 9:50PM on 29th 2008 by Kelly

• 25. I think Brooke is a sweetheart. I love her voice. David Cook is great too!! I liked Carly as well.

  Posted at 9:49PM on 29th 2008 by Kelly

• 26. Jason Castro is the wrost ever singer. He has no skills. Street performers are more talented. I think the judges like him because they realize he should never have been in the competition and they made a huge mistake.

  Posted at 9:30PM on 29th 2008 by Marc

• 27. can someone please post the numbers to call ? tv is busted.

  Posted at 9:10PM on 29th 2008 by kitt

• 28. I think those of you who said on here that Mormons are not christans need to explain yourself... Do you have proof of this? Where do you get your reasoning from? ANd If your answer has anything to do with everything in the media... then you need to listen better... Those people from the religios sect are not apart of the CHurch of Jesus Christ of Ladder Day Saints, They are not LDS they are FLDS... Do your research. I am mormon and I AM Christian.

  Posted at 9:00PM on 29th 2008 by Marie

• 29. Does it "SAY IT ALL", Noah? Moron!

  Posted at 8:52PM on 29th 2008 by SteverB

• 30. Brooke Jason and David Cook need to go home!

  Posted at 8:46PM on 29th 2008 by Amy