"Idol" Top 5 Perform

Reader Comments

• 31. David Cook sucked one big tonight

  Posted at 8:40PM on 29th 2008 by Ashley

• 32. Actually, the word is "enunciating" -- without the initial double ens you mistakenly used. Pot, meet Kettle.

  Posted at 8:07PM on 29th 2008 by madmonkey

• 33. Morons all around here. Neither of you knows how to spell enunciate. And one below doesn't realize the Mormon church is in fact called the Church of Jesus Christ of latter-day Saints = Christians. Or is there something about believing in Christ that isn't Christian? Or do you not want to share 'your' Christ with the Mormons? That's very 'Christian' of you.

  Posted at 8:05PM on 29th 2008 by Correction

• 34. The word is "ennunciating", you moron.

  Posted at 7:55PM on 29th 2008 by rst

• 35. The word is "ennunicating", you moron.

  Posted at 7:53PM on 29th 2008 by rst

• 36. Annunciating your words does not mean you are faking a british accent you hillbilly. And talk about mumbling... have you seen Archie perform?

  Posted at 7:51PM on 29th 2008 by Canihaveacookie

• 37. Mormons are NOT Christians.

  Posted at 7:49PM on 29th 2008 by no way

• 38. So Archie is predictable and Cook isn't? Come on! They both have their own styles which they basically put out there every week. Cook's only divergence from his Emo-mumblings was "Music of the Night" which he sang with a fake British accent--truly embarrassing! Let's face it, some people want a ballad singer with a great voice and some prefer a rocker--simple enough. But the Archie bashing is bizarre. I think there are alot of twenty-somethings out there who can't stand an innocent, good, talented kid. Get a life!

  Posted at 7:43PM on 29th 2008 by rst

• 39. Brooke is, in fact a Mormon. And Mormons are in fact, Christians. Go David and David! Can't wait for Neil Diamond night.

  Posted at 7:41PM on 29th 2008 by ker

• 40. I hope Jason Castro stays, for some reason I just love him, although I think the biggest talents are the Davids.

  Posted at 7:39PM on 29th 2008 by Brittainy

• 41. David Archuletta needs to go along with Jason Castro. David is boring as can be, predictable, and like a puppet on stage. He gestures his hand, stands the same position and his voice is always the same, lame boring monotone performance that has become sickening. He’s there all because Paula wants to rob the cradle once again. If she offered his dad "The right amount" his dad would sell him up the river. Jason Castor needs to stop with the dreads that make him look like the creature in Predator. Show some real talent dude. I know it's there, but stop playing it safe week after week. Bottom line is, this Idol is being judged on who's the cutest, and not who has more talent. Too bad we don't have the ability to vote of judges. Paula would be the first to go. She reminds me too much of a pedophile in progress. I hate saying that, but the way she responds to him on stage, and her past with the other young dude she bedded says it all.

  Posted at 7:32PM on 29th 2008 by Noah

• 42. Its going to be a long long night. Brooke, David A and Jason need to go home. Every week they sound exactly the same.

  Posted at 7:32PM on 29th 2008 by sarah

• 43. I wanted David Cook to do HIM's version of Solitary Man. C'mon, DC, that would have rocked. David kinda just stands there like Ville and does a great job. Man.

  Posted at 7:30PM on 29th 2008 by Arc

• 44. Who is getting these ARTISTS to come on AI and "coach" the contestants? Personally, I think they should have current artists... geesh.. most of todays kids/teens doesnt even know who neil diamond is anyway.. GRR! GO DAVID COOK!

  Posted at 7:25PM on 29th 2008 by christi

• 45. I would like to have heard David Cook sing Hello again with his unique style. It's a beautiful song.

  Posted at 7:23PM on 29th 2008 by hildy