"Idol" Top 5 Perform

Reader Comments

• 46. After last week I almost didn't want to watch this anymore but I am determined to keep poor Syesha in. All you Carly fans out there please vote for Syesha and David Cook because they are the only talented ones left. Syesha doesn't deserve to go home before Brooke

  Posted at 7:21PM on 29th 2008 by Joe

• 47. David Cook ROCKS!! Blow them away!! If he does not win this year~ugh! Simon should have signed him after Billy Jean...this kid is a WINNER

  Posted at 7:18PM on 29th 2008 by lynn

• 48. No talent hack Brooke White doesn't need to be on American Idol. She is just a weirded out neurotic girl who needs some serious meds. Syesha can out class that skinny twit every time she performs. She can perform circles around horse face.

  Posted at 7:15PM on 29th 2008 by Delia

• 49. For those people who think that by putting someone down they are helping their favorite, you guys are idiots!! David A. CAN sing, and so can David C., even though I am more of a fan of Archie - but I wouldnt bash another contestant in order to make my favorite look better! This is a great year for AI, they have a lot of talent this year and a lot of different sounds... Josh Groban is an amazing singer and he just stands and performs... he doesnt jump around the stage and dance, and not everyone needs to... David A. is great just standing and singing... and David C. fans - he usuaslly just stands there and plays the guitar, so how is that any different???? I think both Davids are great in their own way and I think they both have charisma.... I still dont split my votes (I'm for Archie all the way) but I at least have respect for the other contestants!

  Posted at 7:13PM on 29th 2008 by jennjenn

• 50. It'll be the same as other weeks. Syesha will tear it up and get put down by by the judges, David A. will sing a ballad and sound good, Jason will be dull and be overpraised, Brooke will be a bundle of nerves , and David C. will do ok no matter what he sings. Syesha will outsing everybody and then go home tomorrow.

  Posted at 7:13PM on 29th 2008 by Barney

• 51. Wow, Totally not expecting these choices at all:( Perhaps the AI producers are feeding the "moles" some false information (not your fault moles) to make it a real suprise. I can't believe not one person, especially my favorite D.C. is singing "Cherry, Cherry" or "Love on Rocks" or "Solitary Man"? I had built him up singing and rockin' out on those songs. Please,please let my "surprise" theory be correct because otherwise, I really think D.C. has his work cut out for him.

  Posted at 7:10PM on 29th 2008 by TEKM

• 52. Brooke is a Christian, not a Mormon. David A. is, however, a Mormon. Why should we care about their religion?

  Posted at 7:10PM on 29th 2008 by Regina

• 53. Wow, Totally not expecting these choices at all:( Perhaps the AI producers are feeding the "moles" some false information (not your fault moles) to make it a real suprise. I can't believe not one person, especially my favorite D.C. is singing "Cherry, Cherry" or "Love on Rocks" or "Solitary Man"? I had built him up singing and rockin' out on those songs. Please,please let my "surprise" theory be correct because otherwise, I really think D.C. has his work cut out for him.

  Posted at 7:09PM on 29th 2008 by TEKM

• 54. Well since David Cook has no competition left (with the exit of Carly and Michael), he should have no problem tonight. He's the best performer and singer of any of the constestants this season. If David "aw shucks, duh, what is going on" could possibly sing anything but the same old boring ballads, that he usually forgets the words to by the way, even goes to the final 2, he will lose by a landslide. All he has is teeny boppers who can tolerate his stupid persona and him licking his lips every 2 seconds!! Syesha and Brooke are boring and horrible, and Jason has no range, but he should make it to the final 3.

  Posted at 7:07PM on 29th 2008 by Lisa

• 55. Politics, hmmmm..... Cook=arrogant=thinks he can do no wrong=Bush. Arhie=inspirational=talented=Obama.

  Posted at 7:06PM on 29th 2008 by pt

• 56. Why do people bash David Cook for using an arrangement done by someone else? EVERY SONG SUNG ON AI ARE COVERS, PEOPLE. He doesn't try to say it was his version. At least he has enough musical knowledge to know different versions exist that may suit his style better. Also, last I checked...nobody else had covered Mariah's "Always be my Baby". I'll take that over David A's wheezing performances any day.

  Posted at 7:05PM on 29th 2008 by Lola

• 57. I dont realy like anybody on da show. i like jason cuz he alwayz look high. but david A. sounds like a disney mousekateer or sumin, brooke reminds me of the blind chic on top model a couple years back. & thats all i have 2 say about that.

  Posted at 7:02PM on 29th 2008 by GB

• 58. david archuleta is MORMON and so is brooke, i don't have anything against mormons but all these little children that love archuleta and think he's going to marry them are in for a BIG suprise.. wonder why daddy doesn't pimp that part out hmm?

  Posted at 6:59PM on 29th 2008 by haha

• 59. I can't wait to watch David A He is my favorite and only one.. Go davidAaaaaaaaa

  Posted at 6:59PM on 29th 2008 by David Aaaaaaa

• 60. I seriously hope Syesha tears it up tonight... every week people have been saying she's going to go home lol! But she hasn't yet... don't count her out just yet, she's a phenomenal talent!

  Posted at 6:58PM on 29th 2008 by Paul