"Idol" Top 5 Perform

Reader Comments

• 61. David Arch............ YOU YOU YOU!!!! You will be AWESOME tonite! WhY?? Because YOU are the one to beat!! You go David! Bring the house down tonite!

  Posted at 6:58PM on 29th 2008 by rhodyluvsDA

• 62. David Cook is just a fraud. He steals other people's arrangements and people think he thought them up himself. He sings OK but he's arrogant and not as good as he thinks he is. Really at this point, no one's all that great. I assume it will be the Davids in the top two. Brooke and Jason sure don't deserve to be there although I adore Jason and poor Sayesha can't get a break no matter how awesome she is. I still miss Michael Johns!!

  Posted at 6:58PM on 29th 2008 by PT

• 63. Lots of Cook haters. I'm guessing you guys also voted for Bush?

  Posted at 6:56PM on 29th 2008 by Caitlin

• 64. Ok, i have had enough. david a has not even sung yet, and you are already saying he is safe! Maybe you should save your comments until After the show. But Both Davids will take the night! I hope anyways!

  Posted at 6:54PM on 29th 2008 by Devin

• 65. Syesha is probably going to leave regardless to what she sings or how well. That bothers me, especially because y'all will swear up and down race has NOTHING to do with it. No one here can tell me Syesha Mercado doesn't outsing Brooke White and Jason Castro. / hey race card using $?!#@ hmm let's look at past winners... fantasia oh and ruben stoddard WHO WERE BOTH BLACK I'm sick of the race card being used all the time by you people...get OVER IT

  Posted at 6:52PM on 29th 2008 by race card AGAIN!!!

• 66. yeh syesha CAN sing out those other ones except david a. my hearts set on him. and hes part HISPANIC. I <3 DJ

  Posted at 6:51PM on 29th 2008 by allison

• 67. David Cook is just another Daughtry....go home already! Go Jason!

  Posted at 6:51PM on 29th 2008 by katie

• 68. What? No "Solitary Man"? I love that song! It's Brooke's time to go. I am sick if her messing up them weeping to get sympathy. I agree with others who say that poor Syesha will probably go no matter what. She is a lot better than Brooke and even Jason. I think David Cook is taking a chance singing lesser known Neil Diamond songs but he probably found a great arrangement by someone else and stole it like he did all the other weeks so he should be OK.

  Posted at 6:51PM on 29th 2008 by PT

• 69. yeh syesha CAN sing out those other ones except david a. my hearts set on him. and hes part HISPANIC. I <3 DJ

  Posted at 6:48PM on 29th 2008 by allison

• 70. David Cooks sucks and needs to go home! GO Jason!!!

  Posted at 6:46PM on 29th 2008 by Katie

• 71. Sorry, but David A creeps me out. He's like a Muppet! His talking voice is monotonous and droning. Ok, he can sing, but his personality is just boring. David C should win this if it's about an all round package. No, he's not Brad Pitt, but he's good looking and has got charisma, a voice and maturity.

  Posted at 6:46PM on 29th 2008 by Zizy

• 72. of course David A picked those songs, or did his father? either way he'll be right at home singin those happy homo songs

  Posted at 6:46PM on 29th 2008 by sohardtohandle

• 73. David Cook had to pick obscure songs this time because he didn't have anyone else's cover to copy--he's hoping no one knows the song and learns how truly UNORIGINAL he is. And while we're bashing looks here-Mr.Comb-Over Melon Noggin is just plain painful to look at! This is Archuleta's night, hands down!

  Posted at 6:45PM on 29th 2008 by scm

• 74. Yeah, mhm, just rag on the BIGGEST threat to your favorite (ya know, even though we ALL know that Archie rocks anyways :D) David's gonna rock. Get over it hatttterrrsss.

  Posted at 6:45PM on 29th 2008 by Sarah

• 75. Syesha is probably going to leave regardless to what she sings or how well. That bothers me, especially because y'all will swear up and down race has NOTHING to do with it. No one here can tell me Syesha Mercado doesn't outsing Brooke White and Jason Castro. Carly's exit was ridiculous as well. This entire season is horrid and it's not because of the themes. It's because of the talent. David Cook and David A. should head off in the finale with David Cook emerging as the AI. And for those who honestly think Jason should hit the finale, give me a break! That's NO competition for David Cook or David Archuleta and you know it. What are you basing your opinions on...his eyes?!!!

  Posted at 6:43PM on 29th 2008 by Andre