"Idol" Top 5 Perform

Reader Comments

• 91. David A is playing it so save by choosing two of the most popular Neil Diamond songs out there. That kid has got to go. David Cook will put his own spin on things and rock the house like he does every week. Thank god for him or else AI wouldn't be worth anything this season. As for the girls, sorry to say but your time is up. Looking forward to see Jason's spin on the songs. Should be an interesting night for those REAL artists in the runnings.

  Posted at 6:23PM on 29th 2008 by Stef

• 92. Sheesh, don't the producers of this show know that anything older than five years is automatically crap?

  Posted at 6:22PM on 29th 2008 by Tim

• 93. Stop bashing David Archuleta, he rocks and he's gonna rock the house tonight!!!!!!

  Posted at 6:21PM on 29th 2008 by Kelly

• 94. Thanks for the "Taylor Hicks in training line" LOL!!!! I needed something to break the tension- GO JASON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  Posted at 6:16PM on 29th 2008 by gailer

• 95. Great songs for Jason. I love this kid and so want a Cook-Castro finale

  Posted at 6:15PM on 29th 2008 by Lyoness

• 96. Jason's songs seem perfect for him. I love this kid and hope the throwing under the bus stops. Booke and Seyesha need to go. This year is a guys year. Hopefully the finale is Cook-Castro Two real muscians and artists.

  Posted at 6:12PM on 29th 2008 by Lyoness7

• 97. Brooke White looks like a horse.

  Posted at 6:12PM on 29th 2008 by Deb

• 98. This is gonna be painful! Have these kids ever even heard of Neil Diamond? First Dolly Parton and now this? It must be making Andrew Lloyd Weber seem timely and relevant to these contestants....

  Posted at 6:11PM on 29th 2008 by lizzie

• 99. Syesha has finally picked some good songs for her!

  Posted at 6:11PM on 29th 2008 by Steph

• 100. no wonder the ratings is down this year. I have no intention of watching this tonight. It is boring. No offense ... Neil Diamond is a legend and all but who is watching the show ... grandmas??????

  Posted at 6:08PM on 29th 2008 by Nadia

• 101. I have just about given up on this show because of David Archuleta. Seriously, every show is tailored for his creepiness. He is just so wrong. If it weren't for David Cook, I'd stopped watching weeks ago.

  Posted at 6:07PM on 29th 2008 by joy

• 102. brooke's selection is great and also david's (cook)..syesha is leaving the show tommorrow

  Posted at 6:06PM on 29th 2008 by stav

• 103. could david a. have picked more annoying songs? sweet caroline is the most annoying song in the history of life!

  Posted at 6:05PM on 29th 2008 by devo

• 104. david cook would have been amazing with Solitary Man and Girl, You'll be a Woman Soon sung Eddie Vedder style. Too bad!

  Posted at 6:05PM on 29th 2008 by kathy

• 105. David A is going to do great tonight! I can't wait!

  Posted at 6:04PM on 29th 2008 by Howard