"Idol" Top 6 Perform

Reader Comments

• 16. 2 weeks ago Jason was molten hot per Randy and 2 weeks before that, this has only been the worst night for him but the girls have had week after week of bad, David C has had three different weeks of bad David A two - so I say one bad night does not a loser make - he should not go home - I want the three guys till the end. I think that david c will be the winner though I love Jason the most

  Posted at 12:31AM on 23rd 2008 by ann

• 17. And dude, seriously. Jason should have sang something from Joseph. Any Dream Will Do??? HELLO! He would have been GOLDEN with that baby. Who picks something from Cats? AHHH I LOVE HIM anyway and I hope he gets better asap. Totally voted like 18 times.

  Posted at 12:24AM on 23rd 2008 by J Loren

• 18. Jason Castro ~ he is AMAZING. Couldn't you hear him singing that new Jason Mraz song "Im Yours?" I love his vibe and I will definitely be buying whatever he records. It doesn't matter if he wins Idol because he's definitely a star! It should be Jason and the two Davids in the final three. I do think that David A's voice is beautiful but he's a little too "Josh Groban" for me. Either way, they all have a bright future ahead of them and I wish them all well. And I hope Jason doesn't loose the dreds - he'd look naked without them!

  Posted at 12:21AM on 23rd 2008 by J Loren

• 19. I LOVE DAVID COOK!! He's my absolute favorite!! He made the best song choice of them all. (And he picked my fave song from my fave musical!!) ROCK ON!!

  Posted at 12:20AM on 23rd 2008 by Omaha

• 20. David A SUCKED! Personally you don't really mess with something as perfect as ALW's Think of Me, and he made a big mistake with that song. I also think Jason Castro did horribly, sick or not, he just needs to go home. There aren't enough songs he can sing to sound good. Carley was really good, as was Syesha did really well too. I am more and more impressed by her. I felt really sorry for Brooke and having to start over. And finally, David Cook. Phantom is my absolute favorite, and I really respected the fact that he respected ALW's composition of the song and only added in his flare at the very end of the song. David Cook is going ALL THE WAY!!!!

  Posted at 12:16AM on 23rd 2008 by Ash

• 21. I wonder how it felt for Carly to sing a song about Jesus when she is preparing to remove the cross tatoo from her back and on the web her husbands tatoos are satanic??

  Posted at 12:15AM on 23rd 2008 by ann

• 22. WTF were 4 of them thinking. With all the great songs to choose from they picked songs that they could not match with immotion. WHY OH WHY did Sir ALW not show them clips from the productions........then they might have picked another song. Jason, Carly (who I am not fond off) and David Cook were the best. Lets send the rest home tomorrow and get to the finale/

  Posted at 12:04AM on 23rd 2008 by Juicy Lucy

• 23. WTF were 4 of them thinking. With all the great songs to choose from they picked songs that they could not match with immotion. WHY OH WHY did Sir ALW not show them clips from the productions........then they might have picked another song. Jason, Carly (who I am not fond off) and David Cook were the best. Lets send the rest home tomorrow and get to the finale/

  Posted at 12:04AM on 23rd 2008 by Juicy Lucy

• 24. thank God Carly wore something over her arm.....whether you like tatoos or not, people vote with their ears AND eyes and not everyone likes the look of her tatoos up and down her arm. She won't win anyway but this bought her another week. there can only be one winner though and it will be a man named David-I said man, not boy.

  Posted at 11:43PM on 22nd 2008 by kay

• 25. vote like crazy for jason tonight, he still smiled in spite of their comments and he was really sick and did not even make that an excuse. two weeks ago they said jason was hot molten lava and david c sucked so one bad night does not a loser make

  Posted at 11:39PM on 22nd 2008 by ann

• 26. There is a best and a worst here and four inbetween. David Cook has the most talent. Syesha did very well tonight. Jason and Brooke could leave together. And what's up with Brooke pursing her lips all the time..... her time is up. Does it matter who goes home tomorrow or next week or the next? No, it does not because there is only ONE winner. so who should the Idol be? David Cook. He is the best.

  Posted at 11:39PM on 22nd 2008 by sarya

• 27. There is a best and a worst here and four inbetween. David Cook has the most talent. Syesha did very well tonight. Jason and Brooke could leave together. And what's up with Brooke pursing her lips all the time..... her time is up. Does it matter who goes home tomorrow or next week or the next? No, it does not because there is only ONE winner. so who should the Idol be? David Cook. He is the best.

  Posted at 11:38PM on 22nd 2008 by sarya

• 28. David Cook clearly is the whole package. He can sing move whatever! I would rather sit for 2 hours at a concert for him than anyone else. Archuletta needs to sing for Disney. Besides his dad calls the shots.

  Posted at 11:32PM on 22nd 2008 by Bev

• 29. vote like crazy for jason tonight, he still smiled in spite of their comments and he was really sick and did not even make that an excuse. two weeks ago they said jason was hot molten lava and david c sucked so one bad night does not a loser make

  Posted at 11:25PM on 22nd 2008 by ann

• 30. Ahh Jason was sick tonight but he still did not forget the words or stop and start like David A did. He still did not put on that puppy dog and do the eye thing when the judges were so mean, except for Paula. David C should win but I want Jason there with him. Vote jason vote jason 866-436-5708 or 5702

  Posted at 10:41PM on 22nd 2008 by ann