"Idol" Top 6 Perform

Reader Comments

• 31. Archie can sing, but so can a lot of people. But he never moves!!! He just stands there and sings. I don't expect a choreographed dance number, but take a step!!! But, early in the season when he tried to walk and sing, he forgot the words, so maybe not.

  Posted at 10:06PM on 22nd 2008 by Shannon

• 32. I love David A............ i think that he has the best voice above all and it will only get better! I'm not a fan of rock and david c. just dosen't seem all that great to me........ sorry!! of course thats just my opinion

  Posted at 9:51PM on 22nd 2008 by sam

• 33. I WANT TO MARRY DAVID COOK.

  Posted at 9:47PM on 22nd 2008 by MO FAN

• 34. Did you see what David A's dad wrote about gossipmongers. The truth hurts I guess

  Posted at 9:46PM on 22nd 2008 by ann

• 35. Why does everyone want David A. to win??? He clearly has a wonderful voice and it will only get better with time but folks - he's too young to pull this off! He's just not ready...but he will be but only time will take care of that. I also worship at the feet of David Cook....OMG he is awesome - always!!! I think Carly did a great job with JC Superstar...totally her kind of stuff...Seyesha also was wonderful - suited her to a tee...as for the rest - well not so good. DAVID COOK YOU ROCK...

  Posted at 9:26PM on 22nd 2008 by Vicki in Canada

• 36. What a surprise......ALW mentioned David A's eyes. He did try to keep them open. The last part of his song was the best part.

  Posted at 8:57PM on 22nd 2008 by lauren

• 37. Anyone know how David A did?

  Posted at 8:54PM on 22nd 2008 by Howard

• 38. I love gossipmongers. Just throw out any kind of bullsh*t about people. Who cares if there is a scintilla of truth in the mix? David's dad doesn't push him around. His coach has worked with David for six years and has never seen a single instance of it. Naomi Judd has never, ever met David's dad. She might have heard a rumor once. We all know for sure that ALL rumors are absolutely true, right? BS! David’s been schooled in music since age 5? What a load! He took his first singing lesson at age 12. They didn't realize his love of or ability for singing until he was 7. The folks took the kids to Les Miz. There was a tape of the music at home and a week later David surprised them by singing all the songs spot-on including accents. Music is David's life and always has been. The reason he looks so scared on elimination night is that he lives to sing. It's how he expresses himself. He doesn't want to leave Idol because he loves singing so much.

  Posted at 8:42PM on 22nd 2008 by Karen

• 39. So far tonight - - Jason didn't do every well. Brooke messed up an had to start over, ended up just ok. Syesha did a great song. Her best yet. Not sure what it is with everyone and David A. He is annoying. His squinting eyes when he sings makes him look like he is in pain. I just don't see him on stage headlining a tour. Well see, he's on next

  Posted at 8:34PM on 22nd 2008 by lauren

• 40. Jason's rendition of Memory was breathy dreck. 'nuff said.

  Posted at 8:25PM on 22nd 2008 by skippy

• 41. Ahh, Jason is sick tonight and David A wasnt first - vote for Jason to make it just a couple more weeks then he needs to be let go to be the unique one, in a class of his own.

  Posted at 8:19PM on 22nd 2008 by ann

• 42. Cook Is Going To Get Fried Tonight. Served !!!! ARCHULETA RULES. Last week we lost a cook. This week another Cook is going home. CELEBRATE D-COOK HOME.

  Posted at 8:09PM on 22nd 2008 by Archuleta is the man.

• 43. did you see the comments below, back east they saw him already and he did poorly poor little guy. Yeah NO ONE is doing him any favors voting him through, someone needs to get him away from his dad and let him be a kid and sing what he wants

  Posted at 8:08PM on 22nd 2008 by ann

• 44. David Archuleta is going to beat the living sht out of Cook tonight. ARCHULETA RULES.

  Posted at 8:06PM on 22nd 2008 by Archuleta Rules

• 45. Can't wait to see David Cook! That man is a star! Also love Dr. Dread and Tattoo You Carly! Owwwwwww!!!

  Posted at 7:58PM on 22nd 2008 by CookNwithCook