"Idol" Top 6 Perform

Reader Comments

• 46. anyone hear how Jason did? He was 2nd right?

  Posted at 7:58PM on 22nd 2008 by ann

• 47. Yea, you are right, he is just needs more time to grow up and get some life experiences under his belt and away from his daddy from what I hear. That is probably what messed him up tonight, out of his comfort zone?

  Posted at 7:55PM on 22nd 2008 by ann

• 48. I agree Ann, David A always seems to me to be too focused on getting the song technically correct and therefore loses the passion and feeling, or I don't feel it.....David A has picked a tough song but most of ALW's songs are tough to sing sorry I am over 21 so vocal talent is more important than being cute when David A gets a little older, a little life experience and stops worrying about the technical side so much and does music he really feel truly passionate about, if they let him, then he'll have the full package to quote a famous song, we all have wings, but some of us don't know whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

  Posted at 7:52PM on 22nd 2008 by lavender1960

• 49. hope JASON can NAIL the song... to all jason castro fans....subscribe to mi channel http://www.youtube.com/AI7JASONCASTROTV whoooooooooop!!!!!!!!!!!!

  Posted at 7:48PM on 22nd 2008 by kiero

• 50. I worship at the feet of David Cook and it's perfect for him to get this song. My lust affair continues~

  Posted at 7:46PM on 22nd 2008 by Love David Cook

• 51. Archie is my favorite one.. I hope he wins. I bought another cell phone to make more calls and vote for him more and more... hahaa,.. Go Archie! You are my prince!!!

  Posted at 7:41PM on 22nd 2008 by rooting for Archie

• 52. SAVE DAVID A. He will need all the votes he can get with his song choice, not good. HUGE fan calling all ANGELS to stand behind him. VOTE, VOTE AND KEEP VOTING!!! I don't want him in the bottom three. THANKS

  Posted at 7:40PM on 22nd 2008 by Minnie girl

• 53. ALL D.A. FANS, HE NEEDS YOUR VOTES TODAY!!!! The song choice is awful, but let's not let him DOWN, HE NEEDS ALL OUR VOTES, VOTES, AND MORE VOTES

  Posted at 7:36PM on 22nd 2008 by Minnie girl

• 54. tonights going to be interesting!! lol syesha- not a fan. david cook- hope he does good. carly- im actually excited to see this one lol brooke- once again i dont think she has the vocals to pull it off, but she hopefully she put her own style into it jason- hm i hope he doesnt butcher it, but hes been doing good for the last two weeks, so he might surprise me this week. david archuleta- those that are hating on this kid needs to stop. he has sang many MALE songs in this competition, the only "diva" ballad he sang so far is "When you Believe" and thats because he had no choice. choosing a "diva" ballad for tonight will just show his vocal range, so before you go and say he only chooses "diva" songs go through the list he that he sang so far and he only sang ONE "diva" song. >good luck to all of the contestants<

  Posted at 7:33PM on 22nd 2008 by niK09

• 55. No, David A voice is the most studied, by the book, picture perfect - great but I dont see passion, unique or any of that. Sorry just a cute boy stuck in the mold his daddy created for him

  Posted at 7:31PM on 22nd 2008 by ann

• 56. I'm so excited about Carly's choice!!! It's going to be awesome, just wait and see!

  Posted at 7:30PM on 22nd 2008 by Alx

• 57. I'm just hoping that Carly can pull off Jesus Christ superstar! :/ I know she is not much liked by many and i even think i know why but that doesn't mean that this girl doesn't have talent...I think she really just needs to LOOSEN UP a little bit and relax and let her true self pour out.. Does that make sense? I'm excited to hear how jason will portray MEMORY..one of my all time favorite songs...i was actually hoping that carly would sing that one! oh well!

  Posted at 7:20PM on 22nd 2008 by Jeannine

• 58. For 17 yrs old, David Archuleta has an incredible talent. David C is a breakout star already, Jaon is unique, more so than anyone of them, and deserves to be there. Syesha is talented,but not strong enough. Too bad. Carly is probably the best female vocalist, but is trying to bite off more than she can chew, she should listen t0o the judges already!! Brooke is sweet, pure, and predictable, so long Brooke!!

  Posted at 7:15PM on 22nd 2008 by KATHY C

• 59. David Archuleta's voice is the most passionate, uplifting sound I've ever heard. I will never understand how someone could not like him. Hope everyone does awesome tonight! I'm rooting for the Davids!

  Posted at 7:13PM on 22nd 2008 by K

• 60. No NO NO you dont want David C to win and get the kiss of death that only Carrie U has avoided!! I love David c and Castro - get them thru to the end but let David A win and be the - ooooh - idol. Can you see it really? Ya hoo I love David C the American idol rocker dude?? No - let David C and Jason be safe from the ai mold to continue being unique and cool

  Posted at 7:10PM on 22nd 2008 by ann