"Idol" Top 6 Perform

Reader Comments

• 61. Dread-lock boy needs to go home now !!!!

  Posted at 7:05PM on 22nd 2008 by chuck

• 62. David Cook is going to KICK A#$ TONIGHT!!!! Phantom is the BEST Webber work of ALL TIME so for him to sing ANYTHING from it makes me SO HAPPY!!! David A is going to BOMB singing Think of Me. Very FEW people can pull off that song, the notes are complex and high, something he CANNOT HANDLE. When will people wake up and see how BAD this child really is??!!!! We need a good winner this year! We need a rock winner! Look at the success of Daughtry! BIG MISTAKE not having him win! David C could be bigger than Daughtry!!!!

  Posted at 7:04PM on 22nd 2008 by nikki

• 63. I love David Archuleta choice. I don't get why he is so bashed? if he is the most talented singer on that show. I love you Archie, good luck for tonight, you will do great...you will see... and please ignore the haters, they only wish they had your talent..hahaha.. Archie for the win!!

  Posted at 7:02PM on 22nd 2008 by go Archie

• 64. I hope David A wins and gets stuck in AI niche, never to be heard again like the gray haired guy and Ruben. Then David C and Jason can go on to be as amazing unique and real as they can be

  Posted at 7:02PM on 22nd 2008 by ANN

• 65. david archuleta is the new american idol. everyone that doesnt like him get over it.

  Posted at 6:58PM on 22nd 2008 by Kim

• 66. Yes ALW did say that my Brooke was the most impressive out of the girls...... I smell a comebackkk!

  Posted at 6:52PM on 22nd 2008 by CRAM

• 67. Great! David C will be every bit as pretentious and predictable as before.

  Posted at 6:51PM on 22nd 2008 by smarmy charmy

• 68. Cooke and Castro all the way!!! i agree with whoever said that little archuleta kid is only capable of singing diva-esque ballads, that are totally out of touch with current music. weird for a 16 year old boy.

  Posted at 6:48PM on 22nd 2008 by mgr

• 69. Looks like a list with some potential for both breakouts and train wrecks. I'm afraid the ladies may have another one going home tomorrow night.

  Posted at 6:46PM on 22nd 2008 by Brian

• 70. i hope carly bombs and gets voted off. she makes really creepy faces when she sings and her voice isn't even that good.

  Posted at 6:44PM on 22nd 2008 by Lyndsay

• 71. I hope that David A wins and gets stuck in the AI mold. David C and Jason are the ones I hope make to the top two. David A has been force fed music training since 5 and David C already has an album out. Jason has gone on this far on so little. He is so shy he just stayed behind the drums so long, just wait until he has the training behind him like the other two guys. Jason is unique, different and NOT boring at all. I LOVE it how he just laughs with the judges if they make bad comments about him while the others talk back or make excuses. Jason is real, real good

  Posted at 6:42PM on 22nd 2008 by ann

• 72. Wow, the chosen one picks yet another diva ballad. Is he unable to sing MALE songs for some..uhhh..reason?

  Posted at 6:41PM on 22nd 2008 by Fashionista

• 73. I hope that Brooke finally goes home. I cannot stand that pouty face and smart*** attitude of hers. Where's the respsect? This brat needs to be slapped. She may not agree with Simon, but respect him for bring this show to the states and giving bimbos like her the opportunity to be on stage.

  Posted at 6:40PM on 22nd 2008 by Loy

• 74. Carly should have done "Anything but Lonely" from Aspects of Love. It's a rarely done song that would work for her.."Jesus Christ Superstar" is prob. going to be her undoing..week after week she picks big songs with well known artists. Week after week they tell her she doesn't measure up..I don't see how that will change this week.

  Posted at 6:34PM on 22nd 2008 by Brigid

• 75. Whatever David Archuleta sings will be awesome. I love that soaring, passionate voice of his! Plus, he has an inate musicality you just can't teach. I know I'm gonna love it. That kid could sing the birds out of the trees!

  Posted at 6:30PM on 22nd 2008 by Karen