"Idol" Top 8 Perform

Reader Comments

• 1. syesha you rock you better win u go girl

  Posted at 6:11PM on 10th 2008 by ooxsamyxoo

• 2. Carly is the best of the bunch, I saw her sing live at the Irish pub she works in in San Diego and can tell you she is absolutely AMAZING. And, the most down to earth cool chick ever. She should win the entire thing, she has the most amazing voice of all of the contestents.

  Posted at 5:26PM on 9th 2008 by Foley

• 3. I think Michael Johns is a great singer he pulls off songs by Queen that i never thought could be pulled off Brooke White is great she just goes to safe i think she could make it Kristy lee Cook and Syesha need to be knocked off idk y there still on there. David Archuleta has an amazing voice and doesnt know it David Cook has talent and deserves to make it far Carly sucks and chakezie needs to come back.

  Posted at 11:24AM on 9th 2008 by Misha

• 4. Jason was the best of the night. Amazing! Fantastic! Loved It! Kristy came in at #2 for me. Archuleta? Like he's stuck in some Junior Miss(ter) pageant.

  Posted at 10:47AM on 9th 2008 by mike burns

• 5. David Cook should have totally done "Eye of the Tiger" that would have totally been badass.

  Posted at 9:45AM on 9th 2008 by Liz

• 6. Although I just love David Cook to death I agree - his rendition of that OLP song was NOT good. But hey, everyone has a off night now and then - I thought David A did a wonderful job with a wonderful song...loved it! And my next for the top 3 has to be Syesha - she did an awesome job with that song. A most definate honorable mention to Cristy Lee - I've always like her anyway - she was very good last night. The rest...well not terribly memorable. Can't wait for tonight!

  Posted at 8:58AM on 9th 2008 by Vicki

• 7. Wow. Just goes to show that you've got to have an ear for music to know what you're talking about, 'cuz anyone who doesn't think David Archuleta is an AMAZING talen is musically DEAF!

  Posted at 8:40AM on 9th 2008 by Lynn

• 8. David Cook picked an obscure song to sing tonight, however, he can sing anything and he will be safe this week.

  Posted at 8:37AM on 9th 2008 by jamie lynn

• 9. David Cook is obvioulsy the bomb, he might have had a bad night tonight, but is the best candidate to win the competion. Carly sucks and should be voted off, she thinks her sh--t does not stink. Christy Cook did a good job, but is not my idea of an American Idol. David Archuleta was great, and should not be discounted as a contender in the finals. Brooke is great, she just picks the wrong songs, and I hope goes very far with her talent. Michael Johns sucks, this is not a popularity contest, it is a singing contest, and obviously he has no ability to make a career in making a number one hit. Syesha, or how ever you spell her name is ok, but in opinion, does not make a star. Jason is cute, in a feminine way, is only still on board because of tweens going thru puberty. Anyway this is just my opinion and we all have our own. Take it or leave it!!!!!!!!

  Posted at 3:17AM on 9th 2008 by jill

• 10. David Cook is obvioulsy the bomb, he might have had a bad night tonight, but is the best candidate to win the competion. Carly sucks and should be voted off, she thinks her sh--t does not stink. Christy Cook did a good job, but is not my idea of an American Idol. David Archuleta was great, and should not be discounted as a contender in the finals. Brooke is great, she just picks the wrong songs, and I hope goes very far with her talent. Michael Johns sucks, this is not a popularity contest, it is a singing contest, and obviously he has no ability to make a career in making a number one hit. Syesha, or how ever you spell her name is ok, but in opinion, does not make a star. Jason is cute, in a feminine way, is only still on board because of tweens going thru puberty. Anyway this is just my opinion and we all have our own. Take it or leave it!!!!!!!!

  Posted at 3:16AM on 9th 2008 by jill

• 11. David Cook is obvioulsy the bomb, he might have had a bad night tonight, but is the best candidate to win the competion. Carly sucks and should be voted off, she thinks her sh--t does not stink. Christy Cook did a good job, but is not my idea of an American Idol. David Archuleta was great, and should not be discounted as a contender in the finals. Brooke is great, she just picks the wrong songs, and I hope goes very far with her talent. Michael Johns sucks, this is not a popularity contest, it is a singing contest, and obviously he has no ability to make a career in making a number one hit. Syesha, or how ever you spell her name is ok, but in opinion, does not make a star. Jason is cute, in a feminine way, is only still on board because of tweens going thru puberty. Anyway this is just my opinion and we all have our own. Take it or leave it!!!!!!!!

  Posted at 3:15AM on 9th 2008 by jill

• 12. David Cook is obvioulsy the bomb, he might have had a bad night tonight, but is the best candidate to win the competion. Carly sucks and should be voted off, she thinks her sh--t does not stink. Christy Cook did a good job, but is not my idea of an American Idol. David Archuleta was great, and should not be discounted as a contender in the finals. Brooke is great, she just picks the wrong songs, and I hope goes very far with her talent. Michael Johns sucks, this is not a popularity contest, it is a singing contest, and obviously he has no ability to make a career in making a number one hit. Syesha, or how ever you spell her name is ok, but in opinion, does not make a star. Jason is cute, in a feminine way, is only still on board because of tweens going thru puberty. Anyway this is just my opinion and we all have our own. Take it or leave it!!!!!!!!

  Posted at 3:15AM on 9th 2008 by jill

• 13. Does anyone at TMZ know if David Cook was sick tonight because I just took a look back at "Billie Jean" when he was most definately NOT sick or stressed (like he is now), and he looked VERY pale tonight, and I agree with what someone on Youtube said, he looked like he didn't want to be there and like he was tired.

  Posted at 12:25AM on 9th 2008 by Jessica

• 14. Kristy lee Cook is starting to come on Strong... Her voice was Very Good tonight

  Posted at 12:09AM on 9th 2008 by tony

• 15. jason was absolutely amazing tonight!!

  Posted at 11:14PM on 8th 2008 by Jen