"Idol" Top 8 Perform

Reader Comments

• 16. David Cook did NOT pick a terrible song....Our Lady Peace is an amazing band...but he BUTCHERED that @?$!#

  Posted at 10:31PM on 8th 2008 by Emilie

• 17. David Archuleta's performance was great tonight. Jason cute but sorry I don't see what others see as far as his talent. He reminded me of the Song Tip Toe through the Tulips, by Tiny Tim (the hair the instrument the voice) OK maybe a little cuter. David Cook was terrible, Kristy looked great she will probably remain in the competiion for eye candy. My top 4 David A Michael Johns Brooke David Cook Bottom 3 this week Carly Jason Syesha

  Posted at 10:21PM on 8th 2008 by Sue

• 18. Kristy's strong suit is Country, and tonight she reminded me of Carrie Underwood's rendition of Independence Day. I think it was a defining moment for her, and if she's able to continue in that genre, she's got a shot.

  Posted at 9:19PM on 8th 2008 by Stan

• 19. Christy did really well tonight. So did Jason. Carly picked a terrible song (and I love Queen), and so did David Cook. Michael was just ok David A on the hand I thought was terrible. But then I don't get what others see. CAn not believe he will come close to winning.

  Posted at 9:15PM on 8th 2008 by lauren

• 20. Archeleta sings like he has a speech impediment.

  Posted at 9:12PM on 8th 2008 by sarx19

• 21. She's singing Carol King !!!

  Posted at 8:53PM on 8th 2008 by Wiz

• 22. She's singing Carol King !!!

  Posted at 8:52PM on 8th 2008 by Wiz

• 23. Kristy was actually the best so far. Jason was good too. David was crap tonight as was Carly.

  Posted at 8:48PM on 8th 2008 by kross

• 24. Kristy was actually the best so far. Jason was good too. David was crap tonight as was Carly.

  Posted at 8:46PM on 8th 2008 by kross

• 25. Kristy was actually the best so far. Jason was good too. David was crap tonight as was Carly.

  Posted at 8:46PM on 8th 2008 by kross

• 26. yay david a sang Angels when he was about 13 or 14 and it was SO GOOD woohoo!

  Posted at 8:23PM on 8th 2008 by erika

• 27. Wow! Jason's "Over the Rainbow" was so great!

  Posted at 8:22PM on 8th 2008 by Suzanky

• 28. Syesha and Kristy aren't as good as they think they are.

  Posted at 8:10PM on 8th 2008 by Carrie

• 29. YEAHH Archuleta is closing the show! (i think haha)

  Posted at 8:00PM on 8th 2008 by louie

• 30. VOTE FOR JASON! Can't wait to hear it all tonight :)

  Posted at 8:00PM on 8th 2008 by Laur8n