"Idol" Top Three Perform

Reader Comments

• 16. He probably Going home because of Daddy - Producers don't play with Stage Parents... Ask Brandy!

  Posted at 9:55PM on 13th 2008 by sj

• 17. TiggerTiger- Go to your local karaoke bar, you can har people singing EXACTLY to the original song Re arranging the song is something a bit more exciting than BLAH BLAH BLAH Chris Brown remix is he kdding??? He looked like he need a dose of oxygen after those 3 dance moves Puhleeze

  Posted at 8:55PM on 13th 2008 by Ro

• 18. Is Paula going to be drunk again?

  Posted at 8:51PM on 13th 2008 by Jeremy Mayfield

• 19. Is it just me, or does David Archuleta remind you of Adrian Monk...???

  Posted at 8:33PM on 13th 2008 by Deb Cota

• 20. I agree with LW, in the fact that David Cook is SMART enough to steal someone else's RE arrangement of a song and try to pull it off like HE 'thought' outside the box. I was all for DC in the beginning but started to see him for the fraud he is. Chris Daughtry should have been the first Rocker to win, and AI knows it and so does everyone that bought Daughtry's album thats why DC is still in the game.

  Posted at 8:27PM on 13th 2008 by TiggerTiger

• 21. David Archuleta can't win. The poor kid is boring as hell, and it really appears to me like he's got some sort of mental problem. Come on guys, either David Cook or Syesha should win. They actually have talent. :O

  Posted at 7:59PM on 13th 2008 by Lily

• 22. All along I've kind of been pulling for David Archuleta, being the youngest on the show he's a bit of an underdog, but after seeing this week's lineup of songs, I definitely think David Cook and Syesha Mercada have it in the bag. I'm looking forward to seeing how it all unfolds!

  Posted at 7:58PM on 13th 2008 by Anny

• 23. ANYone who thinks David Arch. will sell more cd's than David cook is in for a reality check. Sort of like when Chris Daughtry got voted off and Taylor Hicks won the competition. A few weeks ago, the label dropped Hicks...meanwhile Daughtry has the biggest selling rock album of last year and still going. So...I'm saying all the teenyboppers can vote a thousand times each but they can only buy ONE cd.

  Posted at 7:48PM on 13th 2008 by Angie

• 24. If a Mouseketeer is what you like, Archuleta is what you want. If you enjoy talent, perhaps Cook or Syesha are more to your liking.

  Posted at 7:38PM on 13th 2008 by Lyn

• 25. c0ok will win.get over it "archies".

  Posted at 7:28PM on 13th 2008 by c0okie

• 26. michael johns should be on tonight!! he would do "whiter shade of pale" really good! or "ain't no sunshine when she's gone"he did that on et and he was awesome!!!!!

  Posted at 7:27PM on 13th 2008 by t

• 27. michael johns should be on tonight!! he would do "whiter shade of pale" really good! or "ain't no sunshine when she's gone"he did that on et and he was awesome!!!!!

  Posted at 7:26PM on 13th 2008 by t

• 28. David A songs are BORING why!! on like the others which chose stellar songs Syesha will rock on!!

  Posted at 7:23PM on 13th 2008 by toyin

• 29. LW: just incase you haven't noticed the fact is all songs performers sing on Idol each for 7 years now are other peoples songs. Most of the idols sing them as previously recorded by the original recording artist. The fact that David Cook thinks outside the box, and wants to give it a different spin or wow factor is just the point. He is the most talented on the show. I didn't hear Lil David saying he thanked John Lennon when he sang imagine or Brooke White saying thank you to anyone and so on. So the fact people noticed David Cook's outstanding renditions means people are liking what they hear. You sound totally jealous.

  Posted at 7:20PM on 13th 2008 by Ro

• 30. eeeeesh! im glad i am a jason fan and no longer watching until next week when i can see him!

  Posted at 7:20PM on 13th 2008 by gailer