"Idol" Top Three Perform

Reader Comments

• 31. This show is going to be boring this week!

  Posted at 7:10PM on 13th 2008 by n

• 32. DC gets too much credit. All those songs he "made his own" were already arranged by others who sang them & he didn't give them credit till he got flack form the media & those artists. He sings fine, but give credit where credts due dude! HE is smart to pick those already arranged songs tho. I will give him credit for that.

  Posted at 7:06PM on 13th 2008 by LW

• 33. David Archuleta is a little lying, manipulative @$?#! His voice is monotonous and the judges have been paid to praise him. Sure, with the fix in, Archuleta probably will win but the real talent, David Cook, with far more versatility and vocal range will wipe his ass in CD sales and concert tickets. Good luck Archuleta, we all know your father is up your ass telling you what to do anyway. Get a life and an opinion of your own you whining litte baby. Go cry in Utah, not on stage in LA.

  Posted at 7:05PM on 13th 2008 by Erik

• 34. I'm so excited for David Archuleta!!

  Posted at 7:04PM on 13th 2008 by MK

• 35. Archuleta is awesome. He will win the whole thing next week!! The last three contestants are all greaty, but Syesha will go home tomorrow and Cook will lose next week. Archuleta is the real deal, an awesome singer, great looking, a wonderful person... a great role model. I can't wait to see him succeed.

  Posted at 7:00PM on 13th 2008 by Gatsby

• 36. I can't wait to see David Archuletta WIN American Idol. He is just going to continue to get better and better. I want a shirtless pic!

  Posted at 6:53PM on 13th 2008 by gymbunny

• 37. Syesha has a good voice -- but it sounds like every other singer out there. Being a pop star is about having a unique sound. DC is tops in that department, and though I don't care for Archie's style, his voice is recognizable. Syesha would do well on Broadway where she can use her workhorse voice on a stage, but she'll never make it as a recording artist. She simply doesn't bring anything unique.

  Posted at 6:47PM on 13th 2008 by Jack

• 38. sorry, but Syesha is not all that great-she over performs every week, is boring, i still cannot believe she made the top 3! go DC!

  Posted at 6:47PM on 13th 2008 by kbee

• 39. Archie rocks..I love all his 3 songs

  Posted at 6:46PM on 13th 2008 by Archie#1

• 40. very interesting song choices. i think its gonna sound like a funeral with david A. david C pick one of my fav switchfoot songs so i hope he does it justice. syesha, sadly, is out of the running completely. its already been decided in everyone's mind that there's gonna be a david vs david finale but she should give it her best.too bad it won't be enough.

  Posted at 6:45PM on 13th 2008 by rregy

• 41. I CAN'T STAND DAVID ARCH..HE IS A PHONY WITH A DADDY BACKING HIM UP. DAVID COOK IS BY FAR THE BEST. HE'S THE ONLY ONE THAT WOULD SURVIVE EVEN IF HE DOESN'T WIN! REMEMBER DAUGHTRY?? ENOUGH SAID!

  Posted at 6:44PM on 13th 2008 by Rob

• 42. Archuleta we love youuuuuu hey lil mama i'm glad to be yours.. hahahahaha i love that song/.. good luck for tonight baby! I'll be voting 4 you like crazy haha you are the best singer daddy! Archie for the win!! God Bless You!

  Posted at 6:42PM on 13th 2008 by Archierules!

• 43. Archuleta needs to start a new show on Nickelodeon or I like the cruise ship idea. Tonight should be between David C, Carly and Michael Johns. Do America right people, and vote for David Cook! He is the only REAL IDOL LEFT!

  Posted at 6:38PM on 13th 2008 by Cloe

• 44. to Flag what is your problem you are just jealous of David A talents and looks he is 17 and a prodigy, he will sell millions of albums when he win american idol!

  Posted at 6:34PM on 13th 2008 by Francesca

• 45. If you actually know anything about vocal music, from a professional standpoint, Syesha is the ONLY choice. David A. does well with pitch and range, but his voice tone/quality is airy and nasal-ly. He sings from his throat. David C. torments his vocal cords by screaming/screetching half the time, and is not good with the "mechanics" of voice whatsoever. David A. and David C. sound basically the same week after week. Syesha has proven that she can pull out the softer ballad sound with as much control and clarity as she can belt out the big broadway sound. Her range is marvelous, and voice quality--clear as crystal!!! And as for the Three Musketeers seated at the table--they basically are concerned about one thing: "Is this kid marketable?". Pity. I would LOVE to see Syesha pull this off!!!!

  Posted at 6:34PM on 13th 2008 by Joyce