"Idol" Top Three Perform

Reader Comments

• 46. David Cook sounds the same? Yeah -- Hello, Billie Jean, Day Tripper, Music of the Night, those all sounded exactly the same. ::rolls eyes:: DC has proven night in and night out that he has the versatility to sing anything. On the hand, Archie has proven he can't sing anything except slow, serious songs. I like Archie, he seems like a nice kid, but he Archie-izes everything he sings. It's completely predictable how he's going to sound on any song.

  Posted at 6:34PM on 13th 2008 by Jack

• 47. Ask the folks working at Fremantle. They agree that the AI is fixed for Archu, but now that his dad has got on the wrong foot with Fremantle, they might get rid of David A sooner than later.

  Posted at 6:34PM on 13th 2008 by A1

• 48. There's not enough talent between the three of them to outperform my pet mockingbird.

  Posted at 6:32PM on 13th 2008 by zigzag

• 49. i don't see how anyone can think that da should win this thing. imo, he is so boring to listen to, he can only sing ballads. he messes up everytime he sings something upbeat. i dont know about everyone else, but i think a person can only listen to so many slow songs from someone b4 they want to choke them, like i want to do da. he is not mature enough to win this show, cook has proved himself to be very versatile and can sing ANY form of song. which is why i believe he should win. however it may not work out that way since da's fan base consists of only 12 yr old girls who are gonna sit on their phones and vote all night long. so, once again, who SHOULD go home, may not be the one going home.

  Posted at 6:32PM on 13th 2008 by john

• 50. David Cook has to win! He is the only TRUE talent. Sure, Syesha and DA can sing okay, but can they sell records? DC has written his own material and arranged his own music for the show, can't say that for the others. DA bores me, same tune, same note, same key, different night. When he sings it feels like forever and I just want it to end. He should have waited a few years to enter the contest, maybe grow some hair on his cajones and get a bit more mature. DAVID COOK ROCKS AND WILL BE THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL!!!

  Posted at 6:32PM on 13th 2008 by Sara

• 51. David Cook is the only one of the three left that would actually be able to make it in the real world. How do you market the voice of Archuleta? He would be a younger version of Clay Aiken. Although, it would probably benefit DC to NOT win the title....look at the success of Chris Daughtry.

  Posted at 6:25PM on 13th 2008 by fpnicole

• 52. I cant believe he is singing Chris Brown, I am mad. I hate that song and he sings this? Lost my vote and I voted for him saince day 1.

  Posted at 6:22PM on 13th 2008 by Amanda

• 53. The only good news about Idol tonight is that there will be a song by the late Dan Fogelberg who was a brilliant singer, songwriter, musician, performer and composer. Plus Dan was gorgeous and a god person. He's missed. I hope Idol singer does ruin the song!

  Posted at 6:22PM on 13th 2008 by Linda

• 54. Archie looks like baby frankenstein.

  Posted at 6:21PM on 13th 2008 by kelly

• 55. This contest has been rigged in Archuleta's favour from the start. Little David A looks like an autistic kid singing on a telethon whenever he's on the screen. Even when his vocals are flat,weak or off key, he still gets the judges praises....Yep, the fix is in.

  Posted at 6:21PM on 13th 2008 by Tommy

• 56. David A is amazing! I can't wait to hear him sing my favorite song "With You"

  Posted at 6:20PM on 13th 2008 by TDH

• 57. Little David A is sooooooo boring and he sounds congested when he sings. No one will be able to stay awake during those songs.

  Posted at 6:20PM on 13th 2008 by sara

• 58. ok...first of all...all u haters need 2 SHUT UP!!!!! k cuz first with you by chris brown is R&B not ballad!!!!! n hes done many upbeat songs...have u not herd da past 3 weeks...LOSERS!!! oh n david cook SUCKS!!!!!! he sounds da same EVERY single week its not even cool...i hate him

  Posted at 6:18PM on 13th 2008 by zana

• 59. Yeah! David Cook is singing rock songs by Switchfoot and Aerosmith. He sucks when he sings actual rock songs. He is only good when he is changing pop songs to rock songs. Bye bye ugly Cookie Monster!

  Posted at 6:17PM on 13th 2008 by liz

• 60. there ya go .. archuleta singing lounge type songs again .. he's going to jazz up chris browns' song to sound like he's singing it on a cruise ship bar .... picture carlton banks from fresh prince.

  Posted at 6:17PM on 13th 2008 by raven