"Idol" Top Three Perform

Reader Comments

• 61. Bye, Sy!

  Posted at 6:14PM on 13th 2008 by Butterfly

• 62. Yes, David C changed his mind. Not sure why, but he did announce his personal choice before hearing Simon's pick for him. I'm guessing either that triggered the change or David didn't like rehearsals for the Collective Soul song.

  Posted at 6:13PM on 13th 2008 by Sally

• 63. DAVID COOK FOR THE WIN!

  Posted at 6:12PM on 13th 2008 by Me

• 64. David Cook is the only one who could make it in the music biz. He's HOT, taented, and current. Archuleta can sing okay, but he doesn't have a cool bone in his body. Syesha is just a wanna be diva with a subpar voice.

  Posted at 6:09PM on 13th 2008 by ILOVEAI

• 65. David A. is boring, and he creeps me out!!

  Posted at 6:09PM on 13th 2008 by spittie

• 66. Three slow songs for David A... what a shock. I wish the judges or producers had forced him to sing an upbeat song. David A is talented, but he's one dimensional. You've heard one of his songs, you've heard them all.

  Posted at 6:08PM on 13th 2008 by Jack

• 67. David Cook will be out tomorrow, just watch!

  Posted at 6:08PM on 13th 2008 by Steve

• 68. This is a singing contest, so let get real here people, David A is far the best. OMG David Cook is UUGGLLYY!!!!

  Posted at 6:03PM on 13th 2008 by Tracy

• 69. David Archuleta is the best Idol contestant to hit the stage.

  Posted at 6:01PM on 13th 2008 by Steve

• 70. If they were smart... Cook should've done "Bittersweet Symphony" as he walked through audience. "Mandy" Barry Manilow Archuleta should've done "I Believe" by Blessid Union of Souls. "Dream Lover" Bobby Darin and Syesha should've done "Rehab" Amy Winehouse. "How do I live" LeAnn Rimes. Would've suited each perfectly.

  Posted at 6:01PM on 13th 2008 by Peter

• 71. DAVID COOK...(YAWN) SAME OLD SAME OLD. DAVID A. IS GOING TO TAKE THE TITLE THIS YEAR!

  Posted at 6:00PM on 13th 2008 by elle

• 72. Ok so here is what I think...David Archuleta is gonna be the next one to go. Its going to come down to Sayesha and David Cook and I think David Cook sounds like every other stinkin' rock person out there! Plz don't tell me he is different because he's NOT! Sayesha is the only one who has a REALLY good voice and she is original so I hope she wins! VOTE FOR SAYESHA!!!!

  Posted at 6:00PM on 13th 2008 by Blake

• 73. I'm guessing AI couldn't get it cleared OR he wasn't feeling it with the song.

  Posted at 5:59PM on 13th 2008 by Cookie Fan

• 74. Thank God DC came to his senses and didn't sing that Collective Soul song. It's too monotone -- it would have been a total snoozer. Maybe he read my comment on YouTube about it. :) Much better song selections.

  Posted at 5:57PM on 13th 2008 by Jack

• 75. uh oh...my comment was meant for DAVID COOK! WHOA BABY, HE ROCKS!

  Posted at 5:55PM on 13th 2008 by writergal