"Idol" Top Twelve Perform

Reader Comments

• 1. хех.. +1

  Posted at 12:20AM on 4th 2009 by Fugglulge

• 2. Actually I think Seacrest was the best performer of all last night. He is spot on. Simon is not always right, but Paula is definitely loaded. And the other fat Journey guy on the left, who cares. Carley had the bes performance period.

  Posted at 1:39PM on 12th 2008 by Jason Archiletto

• 3. The best performance of the night was by Chikezie! His bluegrass start and rock finish was awesome. His is the only performance from last night that I would care to download. He performed like he had nothing to lose, and in do so he won BIG last night!!

  Posted at 11:00AM on 12th 2008 by INFOMAN

• 4. I think David Archuleta should go home, he forgot the words, and the way he talks get under my skin. I don't understand what the big buzz is about him, he sings okay but the way he talkes, hooooooooo help me

  Posted at 11:00AM on 12th 2008 by Stacey

• 5. Carley's version of "Come Together" was terrible. She was screaming the whole time. Simon was wrong about that performance!

  Posted at 8:04AM on 12th 2008 by Michael Smith

• 6. the dude that likes to strip for men needs to be thrown off the show !I've seen in the pass show people be removed for way lees then that so tell me what makes him so damn special??? I mean he likes to give naked lap dances to guy!!!

  Posted at 7:34AM on 12th 2008 by Me

• 7. simon is always right. paula is still on the meds. come out come out, ryan. david archuleta was horrible tonight. amanda overmeyer is hideous. jacuzzi was never better. why were the fat assed kardashian pigs featured? pay your credit card bills, oh, that wasn't your card? jason castro is a sweetie. michael johns was a bore, with an accent, and no personality. kristy what's her name needs to go home. drop the basket of fries honey and take the next order. the stripper stunk it up. simon is, always is, right.

  Posted at 3:10AM on 12th 2008 by jason d

• 8. I hate it when people type in all caps

  Posted at 12:22AM on 12th 2008 by Branden

• 9. WOW DO I LOVE DAVID A.HE'S SO CUTE &SWEET!!LOVE THAT SIMON TOO HE MAKES THE SHOW!COULD DO WITHOUT THAT GAYRYAN HE'S JUST SO ANNOYING!CAN'T WAIT TO SEE WHO GOES!!I LOVE THE BEATLES JUST DID'NT KNOW HOW LUCKY I WAS WHEN THEY WERE ALL ALIVE AN NEW! I SAW THEM ON THE ED SULLIVAN SHOW YES I SCREAMED BUT DID'NT FAINT!CIAO FEFE

  Posted at 11:49PM on 11th 2008 by rosemary

• 10. I ABSOLUTELY LOVEEEE DAVID COOK!!!!

  Posted at 11:47PM on 11th 2008 by IVEE

• 11. DAVID ARCHULETA SANG "WE CAN WORK IT OUT" ..... guess he couldn't. He forgot the words. He was not very good. In fact, not many of the contestants were tonight....did like Carly though. Send the Oregon chick home...twangy 8 Days A Week, are you kidding me? The rest of 'em...hope they do better next week if they get voted through....

  Posted at 10:08PM on 11th 2008 by OUCH, MY EARS

• 12. When will this mindless piece of crap TV Show die?

  Posted at 9:31PM on 11th 2008 by Homer

• 13. justahippy, just rent Across The Universe and pretend you were a real hiipie!

  Posted at 8:54PM on 11th 2008 by billy

• 14. Justahippy, How can you call yourself a hippie when you voted for Nixon? "Hi, I'm Justajew, but I voted for Hitler."

  Posted at 8:45PM on 11th 2008 by Oz

• 15. I confess, I'm an old girl that grew up in the 60's, voted for Nixon in '72 .... and I can hardly wait to see the Beatles songs performed again. I don't really care who does them, I'm ready for trip down memory lane!

  Posted at 7:59PM on 11th 2008 by justahippy